Bonomo S R, Davidson J D, Tyrone J W, Lin X, Mustoe T A
Department of General Surgery, Rush- Presbytarian- St. Luke's Medical Center, Rush University, Chicago, IL, USA.
Arch Surg. 2000 Oct;135(10):1148-53. doi: 10.1001/archsurg.135.10.1148.
Although hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) has been used clinically for 3 decades, there have been few controlled clinical trials. Animal models have not been adequate to test the efficacy of HBO in the treatment of chronic wounds, either by itself or in combination with growth factors. We hypothesize that HBO is as efficacious as a prototype growth factor in improving wound healing in a new animal model of ischemic chronic wounds.
Twenty-five aged rabbits and 3 young rabbits had their ears rendered chronically ischemic and ulcers were created down to the level of cartilage. These ulcers were treated in 1 of 3 ways: with HBO, 90 minutes per day, Monday through Friday, for 4 weeks; with transforming growth factor beta(3) at 1 microg/cm(2); or with both modalities combined. Controls were treated with vehicle or hyperbaric room air or both.
This model created an aged/ischemic wound that failed to heal spontaneously up to 26 days after wounding (88% reduction compared with aged/nonischemic controls). Hyperbaric oxygen alone and transforming growth factor beta(3) alone both improved healing rate (only 38% reduction in healing compared with aged/nonischemic controls). Combined therapy produced no additional improvement over either modality by itself.
In aged animals, HBO and transforming growth factor beta(3) were equally effective in improving wound healing. Our data suggest that HBO alone may be more effective in the chronic wound than in the acute wound. There was no additive benefit to combining modalities as has been reported in the same wound model in young rabbits.
尽管高压氧(HBO)已在临床应用30年,但对照临床试验却很少。动物模型也不足以单独或与生长因子联合测试HBO治疗慢性伤口的疗效。我们假设在一种新的缺血性慢性伤口动物模型中,HBO在促进伤口愈合方面与一种原型生长因子同样有效。
25只老年兔和3只幼年兔的耳朵被造成慢性缺血,溃疡形成至软骨层。这些溃疡采用以下3种方法之一进行治疗:HBO治疗,周一至周五每天90分钟,共4周;1微克/平方厘米的转化生长因子β(3)治疗;或两种方式联合治疗。对照组用赋形剂或高压室内空气或两者进行治疗。
该模型造成了一种老年/缺血性伤口,在受伤后长达26天未能自发愈合(与老年/非缺血性对照组相比减少了88%)。单独使用高压氧和单独使用转化生长因子β(3)均提高了愈合率(与老年/非缺血性对照组相比愈合仅减少38%)。联合治疗相比单独使用任何一种方式均未产生额外改善。
在老年动物中,HBO和转化生长因子β(3)在促进伤口愈合方面同样有效。我们的数据表明,单独使用HBO在慢性伤口中可能比在急性伤口中更有效。与在幼年兔相同伤口模型中所报道的情况不同,联合治疗未产生附加益处。