Møller P, Knudsen L E, Loft S, Wallin H
National Institute of Occupational Health, Copenhagen O, Denmark.
Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev. 2000 Oct;9(10):1005-15.
Within the last decade, the comet assay has been used with increasing popularity to investigate the level of DNA damage in terms of strand breaks and alkaline labile sites in biomonitoring studies. The assay is easily performed on WBCs and has been included in a wide range of biomonitoring studies of occupational exposures encompassing styrene, vinyl chloride, 1,3-butadiene, pesticides, hair dyes, antineoplastic agents, organic solvents, sewage and waste materials, wood dust, and ionizing radiation. Eleven of the occupational studies were positive, whereas seven were negative. Notably, the negative studies appeared to have less power than the positive studies. Also, there were poor dose-response relationships in many of the biomonitoring studies. Many factors have been reported to produce effects by the comet assay, e.g., age, air pollution exposure, diet, exercise, gender, infection, residential radon exposure, smoking, and season. Until now, the use of the comet assay has been hampered by the uncertainty of the influence of confounding factors. We argue that none of the confounding factors are unequivocally positive in the majority of the studies. We recommend that age, gender, and smoking status be used as criteria for the selection of populations and that data on exercise, diet, and recent infections be registered before blood sampling. Samples from exposed and unexposed populations should be collected at the same time to avoid seasonal variation. In general, the comet assay is considered a suitable and fast test for DNA-damaging potential in biomonitoring studies.
在过去十年间,彗星试验在生物监测研究中越来越广泛地用于检测DNA链断裂和碱性不稳定位点的损伤水平。该试验易于在白细胞上进行,已被纳入众多职业暴露生物监测研究,涉及苯乙烯、氯乙烯、1,3 - 丁二烯、农药、染发剂、抗肿瘤药物、有机溶剂、污水和废料、木尘以及电离辐射。其中11项职业研究结果为阳性,7项为阴性。值得注意的是,阴性研究的效力似乎低于阳性研究。此外,许多生物监测研究中剂量反应关系不佳。据报道,许多因素会通过彗星试验产生影响,例如年龄、空气污染暴露、饮食、运动、性别、感染、室内氡暴露、吸烟和季节等。到目前为止,彗星试验的应用因混杂因素影响的不确定性而受到阻碍。我们认为,在大多数研究中,没有一个混杂因素是明确呈阳性的。我们建议将年龄、性别和吸烟状况作为选择研究人群的标准,并在采血前记录运动、饮食和近期感染的数据。应同时采集暴露人群和未暴露人群的样本,以避免季节变化的影响。总体而言,彗星试验被认为是生物监测研究中检测DNA损伤潜力的一种合适且快速的检测方法。