Killen J D, Fortmann S P, Schatzberg A F, Hayward C, Sussman L, Rothman M, Strausberg L, Varady A
Stanford University School of Medicine, Palo Alto, California 94304-1885, USA.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2000 Oct;68(5):883-9.
Smokers (N = 224) were randomized to 1 of 3 groups: (a) transdermal system (TNS) + placebo; (b) TNS + paroxetine (20 mg); (c) TNS + paroxetine (40 mg). Assignment to treatment was double-blind. Nicotine patch (TNS) treatment was provided for 8 weeks; paroxetine or placebo was provided for 9 weeks. Abstinence rates at Weeks 4, 10, and 26 were as follows: (a) TNS + placebo: 45%, 36%, and 25%; (b) TNS + paroxetine (20 mg): 48%, 33%, and 21%; (c) TNS + paroxetine (40 mg): 57%, 39%, and 27%. The differences were not statistically significant. The combined treatment was more effective in reducing both craving and depression symptoms associated with smoking cessation. A subgroup analysis comparing compliant participants was also conducted. Abstinence rates at Weeks 4, 10, and 26 were as follows: (a) TNS + placebo: 46%, 35%, and 24%; (b) TNS + paroxetine (20 mg): 64%, 43%, and 33%; (c) TNS + paroxetine (40 mg): 74%, 51%, and 38%. The differences between paroxetine groups and placebo at Week 4 were statistically significant. Although paroxetine may add value to the current standard of care in excess of potential risk, more conclusive evidence is needed.
吸烟者(N = 224)被随机分为3组中的1组:(a)经皮系统(TNS)+安慰剂;(b)TNS +帕罗西汀(20毫克);(c)TNS +帕罗西汀(40毫克)。治疗分配采用双盲法。尼古丁贴片(TNS)治疗为期8周;帕罗西汀或安慰剂治疗为期9周。第4周、第10周和第26周的戒烟率如下:(a)TNS +安慰剂:45%、36%和25%;(b)TNS +帕罗西汀(20毫克):48%、33%和21%;(c)TNS +帕罗西汀(40毫克):57%、39%和27%。差异无统计学意义。联合治疗在减轻与戒烟相关的渴望和抑郁症状方面更有效。还进行了一项比较依从性参与者的亚组分析。第4周、第10周和第26周的戒烟率如下:(a)TNS +安慰剂:46%、35%和24%;(b)TNS +帕罗西汀(20毫克):64%、43%和33%;(c)TNS +帕罗西汀(40毫克):74%、51%和38%。第4周时帕罗西汀组与安慰剂组之间的差异具有统计学意义。尽管帕罗西汀可能为当前的标准治疗增加价值且超过潜在风险,但仍需要更确凿的证据。