Schirillo J A
Department of Psychology, Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, NC 27109-7778, USA.
Neuropsychologia. 2000;38(12):1593-606. doi: 10.1016/s0028-3932(00)00063-4.
For centuries painters have predominantly painted portraits with the model's left-cheek facing the viewer. This has been even more prevalent with females ( approximately 68%) than males ( approximately 56%). Numerous portraits painted by Rembrandt typify this unexplained phenomenon. In a preliminary experiment, subjects judged 24 emotional and social character traits in 20 portraits by Rembrandt. A factor analysis revealed that females with their left cheek exposed were judged to be much less socially appealing than less commonly painted right-cheeked females. Conversely, the more commonly painted right-cheeked males were judged to be more socially appealing than either left-cheeked males or females facing either direction. It is hypothesized that hemispheric asymmetries regulating emotional facial displays of approach and avoidance influenced the side of the face Rembrandt's models exposed due to prevailing social norms. A second experiment had different subjects judge a different collection of 20 portraits by Rembrandt and their mirror images. Mirror-reversed images produced the same pattern of results as their original orientation counterparts. Consequently, hemispheric asymmetries that specify the emotional expression on each side of the face are posited to account for the obtained results.
几个世纪以来,画家们绘制的肖像画大多是模特的左脸朝向观众。这种情况在女性(约68%)中比在男性(约56%)中更为普遍。伦勃朗绘制的众多肖像画就是这一无法解释的现象的典型代表。在一项初步实验中,受试者对伦勃朗的20幅肖像画中的24种情感和社会性格特征进行了评判。因子分析显示,左脸外露的女性被认为在社交吸引力上远低于右脸外露的女性,而右脸外露的女性画像较少见。相反,右脸外露的男性(这种画像更常见)被认为比左脸外露的男性或任何方向的女性在社交上更具吸引力。据推测,由于当时盛行的社会规范,调节情感面部表情中趋近和回避的半球不对称性影响了伦勃朗模特所露出的脸的一侧。第二项实验让不同的受试者对伦勃朗的另一组20幅肖像画及其镜像进行评判。镜像反转的图像产生了与原始方向的图像相同的结果模式。因此,假定特定于脸两侧情感表达的半球不对称性可以解释所得到的结果。