Tilanus-Linthorst M M, Obdeijn I M, Bartels K C, de Koning H J, Oudkerk M
Department of Radiology, Daniel den Hoed Clinic, Erasmus University Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2000 Sep;63(1):53-60. doi: 10.1023/a:1006480106487.
Women with a genetic predisposition for breast cancer are often advised surveillance with physical examination twice a year and mammography once a year from 25 years onwards. However, the sensitivity of the mammography decreases when breast tissue is dense and this is seen in 40-50% of women under 50 years. We therefore investigated whether magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in addition to the normal surveillance could detect cancers otherwise missed. In 109 women with over 25% risk of breast cancer, MRI was performed because over 50% dense breast tissue was seen at mammography and no suspect lesion was seen at the previous screening. MRI detected breast cancers in three patients (2.8%) occult at mammography and with no new palpable tumor, twice at stage T1bN0 and T1cN0 once. Two cancers were expected. MRI was false positive in six women, resulting in two benign local excisions because ultrasound or fine needle examination confirmed suspicion. We had no false negative MRI results. MRI proved true benign in four BRCA 1/2 gene mutation carriers at histologic examination. Preoperative wire localization of the malignancies detected at MRI proved necessary as the tumor was not palpable in the lumpectomy specimen nor visible at specimen radiology. The extra cost of breast MRI in addition to mammography and physical examination was [symbol: see text]uro13.930 per detected cancer. The cost of the detection of one breast cancer patient in our national screening program is [symbol: see text]uro9000. During follow-up of patients with a familial risk in whom the first breast cancer was detected at MRI, MRI detected two recurrent cancers in stage T1bN0 and T1cN0 and one contralateral cancer T1aNo. Breast MRI is promising in screening young women at high risk for breast cancer, as it can advance the detection of cancers still occult at mammography and physical examination; but the cost may be considerable.
对于有乳腺癌遗传易感性的女性,通常建议从25岁起每年进行一次乳房X光检查,每年进行两次体格检查。然而,当乳腺组织致密时,乳房X光检查的敏感性会降低,在50岁以下的女性中,40%-50%会出现这种情况。因此,我们研究了除常规监测外,磁共振成像(MRI)是否能检测出其他检查遗漏的癌症。在109名乳腺癌风险超过25%的女性中,由于乳房X光检查发现超过50%的乳腺组织致密且先前筛查未发现可疑病变,因此进行了MRI检查。MRI在3名患者(2.8%)中检测到乳房X光检查隐匿且无新的可触及肿瘤的乳腺癌,其中2例为T1bN0期,1例为T1cN0期。预期有2例癌症。MRI在6名女性中出现假阳性,因超声或细针检查证实怀疑而进行了2次良性局部切除。我们没有MRI假阴性结果。在组织学检查中,MRI在4名BRCA 1/2基因突变携带者中被证明为真正的良性。由于在乳房肿块切除标本中触诊不到肿瘤且在标本放射检查中也不可见,因此术前对MRI检测到的恶性肿瘤进行金属丝定位被证明是必要的。除乳房X光检查和体格检查外,乳腺MRI的额外费用为每例检测到的癌症13930欧元。在我们的国家筛查计划中,检测一名乳腺癌患者的费用为9000欧元。在对MRI首次检测到乳腺癌的家族性风险患者的随访中,MRI在T1bN0期和T1cN0期检测到2例复发性癌症,在对侧检测到1例T1aNo期癌症。乳腺MRI在筛查乳腺癌高危年轻女性方面很有前景,因为它可以提前检测出乳房X光检查和体格检查仍隐匿的癌症;但费用可能相当可观。