Pollio D E, Spitznagel E L, North C S, Thompson S, Foster D A
George Warren Brown School of Social Work at Washington University, St. Louis, MO 63130-4899, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2000 Dec;51(12):1536-43. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.51.12.1536.
Service use among clients of a multiservice agency serving homeless persons with severe mental illness was examined to determine whether patterns of service use reflected two stages in an adaptation of the transtheoretical model of change. In the adapted model, change occurs in five stages-pre-engagement, contemplation, engagement, the strategic moment, and consolidation. It was hypothesized that rates of service use would be highest immediately after clients obtained housing (the strategic moment) and would decrease in the months afterward (consolidation stage), with the greatest decreases occurring immediately after housing was obtained.
Service use data were collected for two groups: a housed group of 58 clients who had obtained and sustained stable housing for at least 24 consecutive months at the time of sampling and an unhoused group of 55 clients who were matched with the housed clients on month of service entry. Total service use and use of three service types-a drop-in center, counseling, and health services-were examined to test the hypotheses. It was hypothesized that use of services by the unhoused group would show a consistent linear decline rather than a two-stage decline. Linear spline regression using bootstrap sampling methods was used to fit service use data for both groups.
The two-stage solution significantly modeled the patterns of service use by the housed but not the unhoused clients, supporting the hypotheses. For the housed group, use of the drop-in center and counseling fit the model, and use of health services did not.
The results provide limited support for the hypothesized five-stage model for achieving change.
对一家为患有严重精神疾病的无家可归者提供多种服务的机构的服务对象的服务使用情况进行了研究,以确定服务使用模式是否反映了跨理论模型改编版中的两个阶段。在改编后的模型中,改变发生在五个阶段——预参与、沉思、参与、关键时机和巩固。研究假设服务使用率在服务对象获得住房后(关键时机)会立即最高,在之后的几个月里(巩固阶段)会下降,且在获得住房后立即下降幅度最大。
收集了两组服务使用数据:一组是58名有住房的服务对象,在抽样时已获得并持续稳定住房至少连续24个月;另一组是55名无住房的服务对象,他们在服务开始月份与有住房的服务对象相匹配。对总服务使用情况以及三种服务类型——日间服务中心、咨询服务和健康服务的使用情况进行了研究,以检验假设。研究假设无住房组的服务使用情况将呈现持续的线性下降,而非两阶段下降。使用自抽样法的线性样条回归用于拟合两组的服务使用数据。
两阶段解决方案显著模拟了有住房但非无住房服务对象的服务使用模式,支持了研究假设。对于有住房组,日间服务中心和咨询服务的使用符合模型,而健康服务不符合。
研究结果为假设的实现改变的五阶段模型提供了有限支持。