Wolke D, Woods S, Bloomfield L, Karstadt L
University of Hertfordshire, Department of Psychology, Hatfield, UK.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2000 Nov;41(8):989-1002.
The prevalence of direct and relational bullying and their differential relationship to behaviour problems in young primary school children was investigated. Individual interviews were conducted with 1982 children aged 6 9 years (mean age 7.6 years) and 1639 parents completed the Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire regarding behaviour problems of their children. Of the 1639 children with both data sets, 4.3% were direct bullies, 39.8 % victims, and 10.2% both bullied and were victimised frequently (bully/victims). The rates for relational bullying were 1.1% bullies, 37.9% victims, and 5.9% bully/victims. All children involved in direct bullying had significantly increased total behaviour problems, hyperactivity, conduct problems, and peer problem scores, and lower prosocial behaviour scores compared to those not involved in bullying (neutrals). Findings were similar for relational bullying involvement and behaviour problems for bully/victims and victims but less pronounced. Relational bullies had the lowest behaviour problem scores while being rated the least prosocially inclined children, consistent with the concept of a cool manipulator. Overall, direct bully/victims and children who were involved in both direct and relational bullying behaviour had the highest rates of behaviour problems. No relationship between victimisation and increased emotional problems were found. Those involved in bullying behaviour who show externalising and hyperactivity problems in primary school may be at increased risk for persistent conduct problems. Different interventions may be needed for those involved in relational bullying only, both direct and relational bullying, and those with additional behaviour problems.
研究了小学低年级儿童中直接欺凌和关系型欺凌的发生率及其与行为问题的差异关系。对1982名6至9岁(平均年龄7.6岁)的儿童进行了个体访谈,1639名家长完成了关于其子女行为问题的《长处与困难问卷》。在拥有这两组数据的1639名儿童中,4.3%是直接欺凌者,39.8%是受害者,10.2%既经常被欺凌又欺凌他人(欺凌/受害者)。关系型欺凌的比例分别为:欺凌者1.1%,受害者37.9%,欺凌/受害者5.9%。与未参与欺凌的儿童(中立者)相比,所有参与直接欺凌的儿童在行为问题总分、多动、品行问题和同伴问题得分上均显著增加,亲社会行为得分更低。对于欺凌/受害者和受害者来说,关系型欺凌与行为问题之间的研究结果相似,但不太明显。关系型欺凌者的行为问题得分最低,同时被评为亲社会倾向最低的儿童,这与冷酷操纵者的概念一致。总体而言,直接欺凌/受害者以及同时参与直接和关系型欺凌行为的儿童行为问题发生率最高。未发现受害与情绪问题增加之间存在关联。那些在小学时参与欺凌行为且表现出外化和多动问题的儿童可能患持续性品行问题的风险更高。对于仅参与关系型欺凌、同时参与直接和关系型欺凌以及有其他行为问题的儿童,可能需要不同的干预措施。