Brilstra E H, Rinkel G J, Algra A, van Gijn J
University Department of Neurology, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Neurology. 2000 Dec 12;55(11):1656-60. doi: 10.1212/wnl.55.11.1656.
To assess the time course of secondary ischemia and first rebleeding and the relation between the timing of operation and the time course of secondary ischemia in a consecutive series of patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH).
Life table methods were used to assess the daily rates of ischemia and of rebleeding on day 0, day 1 to 3, day 4 to 10, day 11 to 14, and day 15 to 21. The authors compared the time course of secondary ischemia between patients operated within 4 days of SAH and those operated after 10 days.
Of 346 patients included, 220 were operated, 131 within 4 days and 74 after 10 days. The rebleed rate was highest on the day of the initial hemorrhage, then diminished, and increased slightly again during the second week. The rate of secondary ischemia was highest on day 4, diminished after day 10, but peaked again from day 14 to 18 for patients who were operated later than 10 days after aneurysmal rupture. The peak rate of ischemia was much higher after early than after late operation. Although patients with early operation were in a better clinical condition on admission, with a relatively low risk of secondary ischemia, the overall rate of secondary ischemia was as high as in patients with delayed operation. From day 11 to 21 the rebleed rate was higher than the rate of secondary ischemia.
These results indicate that operation is a risk factor for ischemia, especially when performed early. If operation is postponed, it should be planned soon after day 10, because of the relatively high rebleed rate from day 11 to 21.
在一系列连续的动脉瘤性蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)患者中,评估继发性缺血和首次再出血的时间进程,以及手术时机与继发性缺血时间进程之间的关系。
采用生命表法评估第0天、第1至3天、第4至10天、第11至14天以及第15至21天的缺血和再出血每日发生率。作者比较了SAH后4天内手术的患者与10天后手术的患者继发性缺血的时间进程。
纳入的346例患者中,220例接受了手术,131例在4天内手术,74例在10天后手术。再出血率在初次出血当天最高,随后下降,并在第二周再次略有上升。继发性缺血率在第4天最高,10天后下降,但对于动脉瘤破裂后10天以上手术的患者,在第14至18天再次达到峰值。早期手术后缺血的峰值发生率远高于晚期手术。尽管早期手术的患者入院时临床状况较好,继发性缺血风险相对较低,但继发性缺血的总体发生率与延迟手术的患者一样高。从第11天到21天,再出血率高于继发性缺血率。
这些结果表明,手术是缺血的一个危险因素,尤其是早期手术时。如果推迟手术,应在第10天后尽快安排,因为从第11天到21天再出血率相对较高。