Fox P T, Huang A, Parsons L M, Xiong J H, Zamarippa F, Rainey L, Lancaster J L
Research Imaging Center, University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, San Antonio, Texas, USA.
Neuroimage. 2001 Jan;13(1):196-209. doi: 10.1006/nimg.2000.0659.
The mouth representation of the human, primary motor cortex (M1) is not reliably identified by surface anatomy but may be reliably localized by means of spatial coordinates. For this report, three quantitative metanalyses were performed which jointly described the mean location, location variability and location-probability profiles of the human M1-mouth representation. First, a literature metanalysis of intersubject functional-area variability was performed using eleven, per-subject studies, each of which reported a coordinate-referenced measure of intersubject variability for one or more brain areas. From these data, a weighted-mean value for intersubject variability was computed, which proved to be small (5.6 mm, standard deviation), consistent across coordinate axes (x, y, z), and consistent across brain areas. Second, a literature metanalysis of the location of M1-mouth was performed using seven, coordinate-referenced, group-mean studies (71 subjects in all), each of which reported a grand-average location for M1-mouth. From this, a weighted-mean location and weighted values for total variability (interlaboratory plus interindividual) were determined. Using these two literature metanalyses as input data, location-probability profiles were computed for the cardinal axes (x, y, and z) of the reference space, using the functional volumes modeling (FVM) statistical model. Third, an original-data metanalysis was performed on in-house PET data from 30 normal subjects performing overt-speech tasks. M1-mouth's mean location, location variability, and location-probability profiles were consistent with those conjointly modeled by FVM from the two literature metanalyses. Collectively, these observations provide a detailed, consensus probabilistic description of the location of the human M1-mouth representation in standardized coordinates.
人类初级运动皮层(M1)的口部表征无法通过表面解剖可靠识别,但可通过空间坐标可靠定位。在本报告中,进行了三项定量荟萃分析,共同描述了人类M1口部表征的平均位置、位置变异性和位置概率分布。首先,使用11项针对个体的研究进行了一项关于个体间功能区变异性的文献荟萃分析,每项研究都报告了一个或多个脑区的个体间变异性的坐标参考测量值。从这些数据中,计算出个体间变异性的加权平均值,结果证明该值较小(标准差为5.6毫米),在坐标轴(x、y、z)上一致,且在不同脑区也一致。其次,使用7项坐标参考的组均值研究(共71名受试者)进行了一项关于M1口部位置的文献荟萃分析,每项研究都报告了M1口部的总体平均位置。据此,确定了加权平均位置以及总变异性(实验室间加个体间)的加权值。将这两项文献荟萃分析作为输入数据,使用功能体积建模(FVM)统计模型计算参考空间的基本轴(x、y和z)的位置概率分布。第三,对30名执行明显言语任务的正常受试者的内部PET数据进行了原始数据荟萃分析。M1口部的平均位置、位置变异性和位置概率分布与两项文献荟萃分析通过FVM联合建模的结果一致。总体而言,这些观察结果提供了人类M1口部表征在标准化坐标中位置的详细、共识性概率描述。