Alwali S, Marklund M, Persson M
Department of Orthodontics, Umeå University, Sweden.
Swed Dent J. 2000;24(4):145-53.
Night-time use of extra-oral traction for anchorage may cause jiggling, rotational and extrusional forces. The purpose of the study was to test the hypothesis that headgear forces in an anchorage system may increase the risk of radiographically detectable root resorptions on molar teeth. Twenty-one patients were selected among patients planned for orthodontic treatment, in which there was a need of anchorage in a full-bond appliance during a period of at least 6 months. An experimental group of 11 patients was given reinforcement anchorage in the maxilla with an extra-oral traction (cervical-pull) during night. Ten patients in a control group was given anchorage by a Goshgarian palatal bar, or by Class II-elastics. Periapical radiographs were taken of the upper first molars according to a standardised technique at the start of treatment, and at 3 and 6 months. Recordings included also patient compliance, force evaluation and the measurement of tooth movement. Significant reduction of root length was shown for some roots already after 3 months. However, mean root resorption after 6 months did not exceed 0.6 millimeter in any upper first molar root of the present sample. The degree of root resorption was similar in the experimental and the control groups. The hypothesis of a significant effect on root resorption of upper first molars by night-time use of extra-oral traction for a 6 month period was rejected. It is concluded that patients given anchorage by night-time use of extra-oral traction will show similar degrees of root resorption of the upper molars as those in which anchorage is given by a Goshgarian bar or Class II elastics.
夜间使用口外牵引进行支抗可能会产生颤动、旋转和伸长力。本研究的目的是检验以下假设:支抗系统中的头帽力可能会增加第一恒磨牙在影像学上可检测到的牙根吸收风险。在计划接受正畸治疗的患者中选取了21例,这些患者需要在全粘结矫治器中使用支抗至少6个月。实验组的11例患者在夜间使用口外牵引(颈牵引)对上颌进行加强支抗。对照组的10例患者通过戈什加里安腭杆或II类牵引进行支抗。在治疗开始时、3个月和6个月时,按照标准化技术对上颌第一恒磨牙进行根尖片拍摄。记录还包括患者的依从性、力的评估以及牙齿移动的测量。3个月后,一些牙根的长度就出现了显著缩短。然而,本样本中任何上颌第一恒磨牙牙根在6个月后的平均牙根吸收不超过0.6毫米。实验组和对照组的牙根吸收程度相似。夜间使用口外牵引6个月对第一恒磨牙牙根吸收有显著影响这一假设被否定。结论是,夜间使用口外牵引进行支抗的患者,其上颌磨牙牙根吸收程度与使用戈什加里安腭杆或II类牵引进行支抗的患者相似。