Hill R, Davis P
South London and Maudsley NHS Trust, London, UK.
Br J Med Psychol. 2000 Dec;73(4):505-17. doi: 10.1348/000711200160697.
Romantic jealousy has long been of interest to psychodynamically oriented clinicians. More recently empirical investigations have emerged into the causes and treatments of romantic jealousy. What has not kept pace with this interest is a wider research agenda into non-romantic forms of jealousy. While work has appeared in relation to specific groups or topics, such as sibling rivalry, no attempt has been made to draw together the material on non-romantic jealousy. In this paper the theoretical and empirical material on non-romantic jealousy is reviewed in order to answer two fundamental questions. Firstly, is non-romantic jealousy necessarily pathological? Secondly, to what extent is it helpful to subsume all forms of non-romantic jealousy under one term? It is suggested that while non-romantic jealousy is not always pathological, the term non-romantic jealousy may be a useful differentiating term, not least in highlighting an important area for future research.
长期以来,浪漫嫉妒一直是心理动力学取向临床医生感兴趣的话题。最近,关于浪漫嫉妒的成因与治疗的实证研究已经出现。然而,与这种兴趣未能同步的是,针对非浪漫形式嫉妒的更广泛研究议程。虽然已经有关于特定群体或主题(如手足竞争)的研究成果发表,但尚未有人尝试将关于非浪漫嫉妒的资料整合起来。本文回顾了关于非浪漫嫉妒的理论和实证资料,以回答两个基本问题。其一,非浪漫嫉妒必然是病态的吗?其二,将所有形式的非浪漫嫉妒归为一个术语在多大程度上是有益的?有人认为,虽然非浪漫嫉妒并不总是病态的,但“非浪漫嫉妒”这个术语可能是一个有用的区分性术语,尤其是在突出未来研究的一个重要领域方面。