Shepherd J, Peersman G, Weston R, Napuli I
Health Education Unit, Research and Graduate School of Education, University of Southampton, Southampton S017 1BJ, UK.
Health Educ Res. 2000 Dec;15(6):681-94. doi: 10.1093/her/15.6.681.
A systematic review was conducted to determine the effectiveness of health education interventions to promote sexual risk reduction behaviours amongst women in order to reduce transmission of human papillomavirus (HPV), a leading agent in the development of cervical cancer. A comprehensive search was conducted to identify relevant studies. Studies were included in the review if they evaluated educational interventions targeting women only and measured the impact on either a behavioural outcome such as condom use for sexual intercourse, partner reduction or abstinence, or a clinical outcome such as incidence of a STD. Thirty studies met the inclusion criteria for the review; all had the primary aim of preventing HIV and other STDs rather than cervical cancer. Ten of the 30 studies were considered to provide the strongest evidence for a causal relationship between the intervention and the change in outcomes measured. Each of these 10 most rigorous studies showed a statistically significant positive effect on sexual risk reduction, typically with increased use of condoms for vaginal intercourse. This positive effect was generally sustained up to 3 months after intervention. It was concluded that educational interventions targeting socially and economically disadvantaged women in which information provision is complemented by sexual negotiation skill development can encourage at least short-term sexual risk reduction behaviour. This effect has the potential to reduce the transmission of HPV and thus possibly reduce the incidence of cervical carcinoma.
开展了一项系统评价,以确定健康教育干预措施在促进女性降低性风险行为方面的有效性,从而减少人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)的传播,HPV是宫颈癌发展的主要致病因素。进行了全面检索以识别相关研究。如果研究评估了仅针对女性的教育干预措施,并测量了对诸如性交时使用避孕套、减少性伴侣或禁欲等行为结果,或诸如性传播疾病发病率等临床结果的影响,则纳入该评价。30项研究符合该评价的纳入标准;所有研究的主要目的都是预防艾滋病毒和其他性传播疾病,而非宫颈癌。30项研究中有10项被认为为干预措施与所测量结果变化之间的因果关系提供了最有力的证据。这10项最严谨的研究每项都显示出对降低性风险有统计学上显著的积极效果,通常表现为增加阴道性交时避孕套的使用。这种积极效果在干预后通常可持续长达3个月。得出的结论是,针对社会和经济处境不利女性的教育干预措施,在提供信息的同时辅以性协商技能培养,可鼓励至少短期内降低性风险行为。这种效果有可能减少HPV的传播,从而可能降低宫颈癌的发病率。