Arnetz B B
Department of Public Health & Caring Sciences, Uppsala University, Sweden.
Soc Sci Med. 2001 Jan;52(2):203-13. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(00)00220-3.
Fundamental changes in the organization, financing, and delivery of health care have added new stressors or opportunities to the medical profession. These new potential stressors are in addition to previously recognized external and internal ones. The work environment of physicians poses both psychosocial, ergonomic, and physico-chemical threats. The psychosocial work environment has, if anything, worsened. Demands at work increase at the same time as influence over one's work and intellectual stimulation from work decrease. In addition, violence and the threat of violence is another major occupational health problem physicians increasingly face. Financial constraint, managed care and consumerism in health care are other factors that fundamentally change the role of physicians. The rapid deployment of new information technologies will also change the role of the physician towards being more of an advisor and information provider. Many of the minor health problems will increasingly be managed by patients themselves and by non-physician professionals and practitioners of complementary medicine. Finally, the economic and social status of physicians are challenged which is reflected in a slower salary increase compared to many other professional groups. The picture painted above may be seen as uniformly gloomy. In reality, that is not the case. There is growing interest in and awareness of the importance of the psychosocial work environment for the delivery of high quality care. Physicians under stress are more likely to treat patients poorly, both medically and psychologically. They are also more prone to make errors of judgment. Studies where physicians' work environment in entire hospitals has been assessed, results fed-back, and physicians and management have worked with focused improvement processes, have demonstrated measurable improvements in the ratings of the psychosocial work environment. However, it becomes clear from such studies that quality of the leadership and the physician team impact on the overall work atmosphere. Physicians unaware of the goals of the department as well as the hospital, that do not receive management performance feedback, and who do not get annual performance appraisals and career guidance, rate their psychosocial environment as more adverse than their colleagues. There is also a great need to offer personally targeted competence development plans. Heads of department and senior physicians rate their work environment as of higher quality than more junior and mid-career physicians. More specifically, less senior physicians perceive similar work demands as their senior colleagues but rate influence over work, skills utilization, and intellectual stimulation at work as significantly worse. In order to combat negative stressors in the physicians' work environment, enhancement initiatives should be considered both at the individual, group, and structural level. Successful resources used by physicians to manage the stress of everyday medicine should be identified. Physicians are a key group to ensure a well-functioning health care system. In order to be able to change and adapt to the ongoing evolution of the Western health care system, more focus needs to be put on the psychosocial aspects of physicians' work.
医疗保健的组织、融资和提供方式发生的根本性变化,给医学专业带来了新的压力源或机遇。这些新的潜在压力源是在先前已认识到的外部和内部压力源之外的。医生的工作环境带来了心理社会、人体工程学和物理化学方面的威胁。心理社会工作环境如果有什么变化的话,那就是变得更糟了。工作需求增加的同时,对工作的影响力和工作带来的智力刺激却在减少。此外,暴力以及暴力威胁是医生越来越多地面临的另一个主要职业健康问题。经济限制、管理式医疗和医疗保健中的消费主义是从根本上改变医生角色的其他因素。新信息技术的迅速应用也将改变医生的角色,使其更多地成为顾问和信息提供者。许多小的健康问题将越来越多地由患者自己以及非医生专业人员和补充医学从业者来处理。最后,医生的经济和社会地位受到挑战,这体现在与许多其他专业群体相比,他们的薪资增长较为缓慢。上面描绘的情况可能被视为一概黯淡。但实际上并非如此。人们对心理社会工作环境对提供高质量医疗保健的重要性的兴趣和认识在不断增加。处于压力下的医生在医疗和心理方面更有可能对患者治疗不佳。他们也更容易出现判断失误。在对整个医院医生的工作环境进行评估、反馈结果,并且医生和管理层共同致力于有针对性的改进过程的研究中,已经证明心理社会工作环境的评分有了可衡量的改善。然而,从这类研究中可以清楚地看出,领导能力和医生团队的素质会影响整体工作氛围。不了解科室以及医院目标、没有得到管理层绩效反馈、没有接受年度绩效评估和职业指导的医生,对其心理社会环境的评价比同事更负面。也非常需要提供针对个人的能力发展计划。科室主任和资深医生对其工作环境的评价高于初级和处于职业生涯中期的医生。更具体地说,资历较浅的医生认为他们与资深同事有相似的工作要求,但对工作的影响力、技能运用和工作中的智力刺激的评价明显更差。为了应对医生工作环境中的负面压力源,应在个人、团队和结构层面考虑强化举措。应确定医生用于应对日常医疗压力的成功资源。医生是确保医疗保健系统良好运作的关键群体。为了能够改变并适应西方医疗保健系统的持续演变,需要更多地关注医生工作的心理社会方面。