Patton L L
Department of Dental Ecology, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 27599-7450, USA.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2001 Feb;29(1):23-9.
To assess the accuracy of HIV/AIDS patients' self-diagnosis of common HIV-related oral opportunistic infections.
245 HIV/AIDS patients were interviewed regarding the current presence of oral candidiasis (OC), oral hairy leukoplakia (OHL), and oral ulcers prior to an oral examination by an oral medicine trained dentist examiner. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) are reported for the patient's oral lesion diagnosis compared to the dentist's diagnosis based on established presumptive clinical criteria as the gold standard.
Self-diagnosis accuracy was greatest for pseudomembraneous OC (PPV 42.9%; NPV 93.5%), followed by oral ulcers (PPV 35.7%; NPV 98.3%) and OHL (PPV 23.5%; NPV 86.4%). Past experience with the lesion improved diagnostic accuracy, and bothersome symptoms accompanying the lesion had significant impact only for pseudomembraneous OC and oral ulcers.
Moderate accuracy of patient self-assessment of oral lesions, with tendency to under rather than over report lesion presence, supports the use of patient self-assessment of these lesions to augment clinician diagnosis in clinical trials. Additionally, HIV/AIDS patients are unlikely to believe they have active OC that would lead to on-demand antifungal use, unless they have had prior experience with the lesion or it is at least moderately bothersome.
评估艾滋病病毒/艾滋病(HIV/AIDS)患者对常见的与HIV相关口腔机会性感染的自我诊断准确性。
在经过口腔医学培训的牙医进行口腔检查之前,对245例HIV/AIDS患者就当前是否存在口腔念珠菌病(OC)、口腔毛状白斑(OHL)和口腔溃疡进行了访谈。与基于既定的推定临床标准作为金标准的牙医诊断相比,报告了患者口腔病变诊断的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值(PPV)和阴性预测值(NPV)。
假膜性OC的自我诊断准确性最高(PPV 42.9%;NPV 93.5%),其次是口腔溃疡(PPV 35.7%;NPV 98.3%)和OHL(PPV 23.5%;NPV 86.4%)。既往病变经历提高了诊断准确性,且病变伴随的困扰症状仅对假膜性OC和口腔溃疡有显著影响。
患者对口腔病变的自我评估准确性中等,倾向于少报而非多报病变的存在,这支持在临床试验中利用患者对这些病变的自我评估来辅助临床医生的诊断。此外,除非HIV/AIDS患者既往有过病变经历或病变至少有中度困扰,否则他们不太可能认为自己患有会导致按需使用抗真菌药物的活动性OC。