Tamada T, Sone T, Tomomitsu T, Jo Y, Tanaka H, Fukunaga M
Department of Radiology, Kawasaki Medical School, Okayama, Japan.
J Bone Miner Metab. 2001;19(1):45-51. doi: 10.1007/s007740170059.
In the present study, we investigated the diagnostic effectiveness of biochemical markers of bone turnover for the detection of bone metastasis from prostate cancer and changes in the levels of these markers caused by hormonal therapy. Ninety-five patients with prostate cancer were divided into one of three groups: 26 patients with bone metastasis (BM(+)), 35 patients without bone metastasis on nonhormonal therapy (BM(-)HT(-)) and 34 patients without bone metastasis on hormonal therapy (BM(-)HT(+)). All patients in the BM(+) group had received hormonal therapy. Serum or urinary levels of the following biochemical markers of bone turnover were examined: bone-specific alkaline phosphatase (B-ALP), osteocalcin (OC), type I procoIlagen C-propeptide (PICP), type I collagen cross-linked C-telopeptide (ICTP), C-telopeptide fragment (CTx), N-telopeptide fragment (NTx), total pyridinoline (T-Pyr), total deoxypyridinoline (T-D-Pyr) and free deoxypyridinoline (F-D-Pyr). The BM(+) group showed significantly higher values than the BM(-)HT(-) group for B-ALP, PICP, NTx, CTx, T-Pyr, T-D-Pyr, and F-D-Pyr. Compared with the BM(-)HT(+) group, the BM(-) group showed significantly higher values for B-ALP, ICTP, NTx, T-Pyr and T-D-Pyr. The levels of B-ALP, NTx, CTx, T-D-Pyr and F-D-Pyr were significantly different between the BM(-)HT(-) and BM(-)HT(+) groups. All markers, except OC and CTx, significantly were correlated with the extent of bone metastasis on bone scintigraphy. Of all markers, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analyses revealed B-ALP and F-D-Pyr to be the most sensitive and specific for differentiation between the BM(+) and BM(-)HT(-) groups with regard to bone formation and resorption. respectively. In contrast, B-ALP and ICTP were most sensitive and specific for differentiation between the BM(+) and BM(-)HT(+) groups. The results suggest that hormonal therapy greatly affects the efficacy of PICP, CTx and F-D-Pyr in the diagnosis of bone metastasis, whereas its effects on ICTP are small. Although bone metabolic markers would be useful in the diagnosis of bone metastasis from prostate cancer, the effects of hormonal therapy on bone metabolism should be kept in mind in their evaluation.
在本研究中,我们调查了骨转换生化标志物对前列腺癌骨转移的诊断效能以及激素治疗引起的这些标志物水平的变化。95例前列腺癌患者被分为三组之一:26例有骨转移的患者(BM(+)),35例接受非激素治疗且无骨转移的患者(BM(-)HT(-)),以及34例接受激素治疗且无骨转移的患者(BM(-)HT(+))。BM(+)组的所有患者均接受过激素治疗。检测了以下骨转换生化标志物的血清或尿液水平:骨特异性碱性磷酸酶(B-ALP)、骨钙素(OC)、I型前胶原C端前肽(PICP)、I型胶原交联C末端肽(ICTP)、C末端肽片段(CTx)、N末端肽片段(NTx)、总吡啶啉(T-Pyr)、总脱氧吡啶啉(T-D-Pyr)和游离脱氧吡啶啉(F-D-Pyr)。BM(+)组的B-ALP、PICP、NTx、CTx、T-Pyr、T-D-Pyr和F-D-Pyr值显著高于BM(-)HT(-)组。与BM(-)HT(+)组相比,BM(-)组的B-ALP、ICTP、NTx、T-Pyr和T-D-Pyr值显著更高。BM(-)HT(-)组和BM(-)HT(+)组之间的B-ALP、NTx、CTx、T-D-Pyr和F-D-Pyr水平存在显著差异。除OC和CTx外,所有标志物均与骨闪烁显像上的骨转移程度显著相关。在所有标志物中,受试者工作特征(ROC)分析显示,就骨形成和骨吸收而言,B-ALP和F-D-Pyr对区分BM(+)组和BM(-)HT(-)组最为敏感和特异。相比之下,B-ALP和ICTP对区分BM(+)组和BM(-)HT(+)组最为敏感和特异。结果表明,激素治疗对PICP、CTx和F-D-Pyr在骨转移诊断中的效能有很大影响,而对ICTP的影响较小。虽然骨代谢标志物对前列腺癌骨转移的诊断有用,但在评估时应考虑激素治疗对骨代谢的影响。