Ward A J, Dixon B
Clin Radiol. 1979 Jul;30(4):383-7. doi: 10.1016/s0009-9260(79)80213-5.
Since 1971, 82 patients with advanced carcinoma of the cervix have been included in a randomised clinical trial in association with the Working Party on Radiotherapy and Hyperbaric Oxygen of the Medical Research Council. External irradiation was given in 10 fractions by an unconventional schedule, either in air or HBO, and combined with three large fractions of intracavitary irradiation using the Cathetron. The results are acceptable overall, with 69% local control, 15% with tumour developing outside the treated volume and 40% survival at five years, but no improvement has been shown with HBO. Symptoms suggestive of some degree of late damage to the small bowel were present in 13% of patients, with a higher but not statistically significant, incidence in the HBO group. It is postulated that the schedule of radiotherapy used has allowed reoxygenation during treatment and that no further gain due to the use of HBO may be achieved. After a review of the results from other centres and taking into account the difficulties of treatment in HBO it is concluded that for advanced carcinoma of the cervix the addition of HBO to radiotherapy is not clinically worthwhile.
自1971年以来,82例晚期宫颈癌患者被纳入一项与医学研究理事会放疗与高压氧治疗工作组相关的随机临床试验。采用非常规方案,在空气中或高压氧环境下分10次给予外照射,并结合使用卡特龙(Cathetron)进行3次大剂量腔内照射。总体结果尚可,局部控制率为69%,15%的患者肿瘤在治疗区域外进展,五年生存率为40%,但高压氧治疗未显示出改善效果。13%的患者出现提示小肠有一定程度晚期损伤的症状,高压氧治疗组的发生率更高,但无统计学意义。据推测,所采用的放疗方案在治疗期间允许再氧合,且使用高压氧治疗可能无法进一步获益。在回顾其他中心的结果并考虑到高压氧治疗的困难后,得出结论:对于晚期宫颈癌,放疗联合高压氧治疗在临床上并无价值。