Rotstein A, Meckel Y
Zinman College for Physical Education and Sport Science, Wingate Institute, Netanya, Israel.
Eur J Appl Physiol. 2000 Dec;83(6):545-50. doi: 10.1007/s004210000308.
The purpose of the present investigation was to examine the relationship between the percent heart rate reserve (%HRR) in arm exercise and the corresponding percent oxygen uptake (VO2) reserve, and to compare this relationship to that occurring in running. Fourteen male physical education students took part in the study. Each subject performed a maximal running exercise test and a maximal arm cycling test. The subjects also performed three submaximal exercise bouts (in both exercise modes) at 30%, 60% and 80% of their HRR. The subjects were monitored for their heart rate (HR) at rest, maximal HR (HRmax), HR at submaximal work loads. maximal VO2 (VO2max), VO2 at rest and VO2 at submaximal loads. For each subject, load and exercise mode, %HRR and %VO2 reserve were calculated (from HRmax and VO2max as measured during running and arm cycling) and the relationship between the two was evaluated. The main finding of the present investigation is that the prediction of %VO2 reserve in arm cycling from %HRR is grossly overestimated when calculated from HRmax and VO2max measured during running. The prediction is better but still overestimated when calculated from HRmax and VO2max measured during arm cycling. The findings indicate a better prediction of %VO2 reserve from %HRR for running than for arm exercise. These findings should be taken into consideration when prescribing the target HR for arm training.
本研究的目的是探讨手臂运动中心率储备百分比(%HRR)与相应的摄氧量(VO₂)储备百分比之间的关系,并将这种关系与跑步时的情况进行比较。14名男性体育专业学生参与了这项研究。每位受试者都进行了一次最大跑步运动测试和一次最大手臂骑行测试。受试者还在其心率储备的30%、60%和80%水平下进行了三次次最大运动(两种运动模式下均进行)。对受试者在静息心率(HR)、最大心率(HRmax)、次最大工作负荷时的心率、最大摄氧量(VO₂max)、静息时的VO₂以及次最大负荷时的VO₂进行了监测。对于每位受试者、负荷和运动模式,计算了%HRR和%VO₂储备(根据跑步和手臂骑行时测量的HRmax和VO₂max),并评估了两者之间的关系。本研究的主要发现是,根据跑步时测量的HRmax和VO₂max计算,从%HRR预测手臂骑行中的%VO₂储备被严重高估。从手臂骑行时测量的HRmax和VO₂max计算时,预测效果较好但仍被高估。研究结果表明,与手臂运动相比,从%HRR预测跑步中的%VO₂储备效果更好。在规定手臂训练的目标心率时,应考虑这些发现。