Reid C M, Maher T, Jennings G L
Alfred and Baker Medical Unit, Baker Medical Research Institute, Melbourne, Australia.
Blood Press. 2000;9(5):267-74. doi: 10.1080/080370500448650.
The HEART project was conducted in general practice to determine whether lifestyle strategies, aimed at increasing physical activity and dietary modification, can be substituted for drug therapy in patients who have been well controlled on antihypertensive medication. In addition to blood pressure (BP) and risk factor outcomes, lifestyle behaviours, quality of life of patients, and the acceptability of the approach to both general practitioners (GPs) and patients involved in the trial were assessed. Patients (n = 45) with a history of hypertension and who had been well controlled for at least the past 6 months (BP < 160/ 95 mmHg) were randomised to a continued medication (C) group (n = 24) or a withdrawal (W) group (n = 21). Subjects had received antihypertensive therapy for an average of 7.8 years (range 1-28 years). Drug therapy in the W group was recommenced if BP exceeded 160/95 mmHg on two consecutive visits. Both groups were counselled regarding lifestyle behaviour change by their GP throughout the study and were provided with specifically developed self-help materials. Subjects were reviewed at least monthly over a 9-month period. Following randomisation, there were no significant differences between the two groups for BP, heart rate, age, duration of therapy, total cholesterol or body mass index. All but three subjects (one from the W and two from the C group) completed 9 months of monitoring following randomisation and there were no cardiovascular events; 71% of subjects remained off drug therapy and were well controlled at the 9-month follow-up (15/21) with mean BP of 141/85 mmHg (W) and 139/ 86 mmHg (C). Systolic BP tended to increase during the study period in both W and C groups, however, no significant differences were observed in mean systolic or diastolic BP either between the two groups or within each group in comparison to baseline values. Resting heart rate, body mass index and cholesterol levels remained unchanged in both W and C groups after 9 months follow-up. There were no changes attributable to the lifestyle intervention in the subjects continuing drug therapy in BP or lifestyle variables over the study period. However, the group stopping therapy had a 6% reduction in body mass index after 9 months. These data suggest that a proportion of motivated patients willing to trial a lifestyle approach can cease drug therapy and be adequately maintained by the prescription of lifestyle advice via their GP for at least a 9-month period. Cessation of drug therapy may be an important motivating factor to achieve weight loss in this group.
心脏研究项目在全科医疗中开展,以确定旨在增加体力活动和改善饮食的生活方式策略是否可替代已通过抗高血压药物得到良好控制的患者的药物治疗。除了血压(BP)和风险因素结果外,还评估了生活方式行为、患者的生活质量以及该方法对参与试验的全科医生(GPs)和患者的可接受性。有高血压病史且在过去至少6个月内血压得到良好控制(BP<160/95mmHg)的患者(n = 45)被随机分为继续用药(C)组(n = 24)或停药(W)组(n = 21)。受试者接受抗高血压治疗的平均时间为7.8年(范围1 - 28年)。如果W组患者连续两次就诊时血压超过160/95mmHg,则重新开始药物治疗。在整个研究过程中,两组患者的全科医生都就生活方式行为改变给予了指导,并提供了专门编写的自助材料。在9个月的时间里,至少每月对受试者进行一次复查。随机分组后,两组在血压、心率、年龄、治疗持续时间、总胆固醇或体重指数方面没有显著差异。除三名受试者(一名来自W组,两名来自C组)外,所有受试者在随机分组后均完成了9个月的监测,且未发生心血管事件;在9个月的随访中,71%的受试者停止了药物治疗且血压得到良好控制(W组15/21,平均血压为141/85mmHg;C组平均血压为139/86mmHg)。在研究期间,W组和C组的收缩压均有升高趋势,然而,两组之间或每组内与基线值相比,平均收缩压或舒张压均未观察到显著差异。9个月随访后,W组和C组的静息心率、体重指数和胆固醇水平均保持不变。在研究期间,继续接受药物治疗的受试者在血压或生活方式变量方面没有因生活方式干预而发生变化。然而,停药组在9个月后体重指数下降了6%。这些数据表明,一部分有积极性的患者愿意尝试生活方式干预方法,可以停止药物治疗,并通过全科医生开具的生活方式建议至少维持9个月。停药可能是促使该组患者体重减轻的一个重要因素。