Valaitis R, Hesch R, Passarelli C, Sheehan D, Sinton J
Hamilton-Wentworth, Social and Public Health Services Division, McMaster University.
Can J Public Health. 2000 Nov-Dec;91(6):411-7. doi: 10.1007/BF03404819.
This systematic review investigated the relationship between early childhood caries (ECC) and breastfeeding. The systematic review methodology used by the Cochrane Collaboration was modified and adopted for this review. 28 of 151 articles (18.5%) were relevant for the study and were rated as strong (0), moderate (3), weak (9) or very weak (16). Validity scores indicated whether a study met the reviewer's criteria for research rigour. The percentage of studies that received a passing score for each criterion examined were: study design (3.6%), confounders (21%), data collection method (54%), definition of ECC (57%), dental health practices (28%) and infant feeding practices (4%). A lack of methodological consistency related to the study of the association of breastfeeding and ECC, and inconsistent definitions of ECC and breastfeeding, make it difficult to draw conclusions. Moderate articles indicate that breastfeeding for over one year and at night beyond eruption of teeth may be associated with ECC. Due to conflicting findings in less rigorous research studies, no definitive time at which an infant should be weaned was determined, and parents should begin an early and consistent mouth care regime.
本系统评价研究了幼儿龋齿(ECC)与母乳喂养之间的关系。本评价采用了经修改的Cochrane协作网的系统评价方法。151篇文章中有28篇(18.5%)与本研究相关,并被评为强(0)、中(3)、弱(9)或非常弱(16)。效度评分表明一项研究是否符合评价者对研究严谨性的标准。每项审查标准获得及格分数的研究百分比分别为:研究设计(3.6%)、混杂因素(21%)、数据收集方法(54%)、ECC的定义(57%)、口腔卫生习惯(28%)和婴儿喂养习惯(4%)。与母乳喂养和ECC关联研究相关的方法缺乏一致性,以及ECC和母乳喂养的定义不一致,使得难以得出结论。中等强度的文章表明,母乳喂养超过一年以及在牙齿萌出后夜间喂奶可能与ECC有关。由于不太严谨的研究中存在相互矛盾的结果,未确定婴儿应该断奶的确切时间,家长应尽早开始并持续进行口腔护理。