Van Gysel W D, Vercammen J, Debruyne F
Department of ENT, Head and Neck Surgery, U.Z. St. Rafaël, Kapucijnenvoer 33, B-3000 Leuven.
Acta Otorhinolaryngol Belg. 2001;55(1):49-55.
If people are asked to discriminate visually the two individuals of a monozygotic twin (MT), they mostly get into trouble. Does this problem also exist when listening to twin voices? Twenty female and 10 male MT voices were randomly assembled with one "strange" voice to get voice trios. The listeners (10 female students in Speech and Language Pathology) were asked to label the twins (voices 1-2, 1-3 or 2-3) in two conditions: two standard sentences read aloud and a 2.5-second midsection of a sustained /a/. The proportion correctly labelled twins was for female voices 82% and 63% and for male voices 74% and 52% for the sentences and the sustained /a/ respectively, both being significantly greater than chance (33%). The acoustic analysis revealed a high intra-twin correlation for the speaking fundamental frequency (SFF) of the sentences and the fundamental frequency (F0) of the sustained /a/. So the voice pitch could have been a useful characteristic in the perceptual identification of the twins. We conclude that there is a greater perceptual resemblance between the voices of identical twins than between voices without genetic relationship. The identification however is not perfect. The voice pitch possibly contributes to the correct twin identifications.
如果要求人们通过视觉辨别同卵双胞胎中的两个人,他们大多会遇到困难。那么在听双胞胎的声音时,这个问题是否也存在呢?将20名女性和10名男性同卵双胞胎的声音与一个“陌生”声音随机组合成声音三重奏。要求听众(10名言语和语言病理学专业的女学生)在两种情况下对双胞胎(声音1 - 2、1 - 3或2 - 3)进行标记:朗读两个标准句子以及一个2.5秒的持续/a/音中间部分。对于句子和持续/a/音,正确标记双胞胎声音的比例,女性声音分别为82%和63%,男性声音分别为74%和52%,两者均显著高于随机概率(33%)。声学分析显示,句子的说话基频(SFF)和持续/a/音的基频(F0)在双胞胎之间具有高度相关性。因此,音高可能是在感知上识别双胞胎的一个有用特征。我们得出结论,同卵双胞胎的声音之间在感知上的相似性比没有遗传关系的声音之间更大。然而,这种识别并不完美。音高可能有助于正确识别双胞胎。