Pomerantz E M, Saxon J L
Department of Psychology, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 61820, USA.
Child Dev. 2001 Jan-Feb;72(1):152-73. doi: 10.1111/1467-8624.00271.
It has generally been taken for granted that conceiving of ability as stable leads to negative self-evaluative processes, particularly in the face of failure. Yet, a close examination of the empirical findings suggests that the picture may be more complex. In this research, a three-wave longitudinal design spanning 12 months was employed. Older elementary school children (N = 932) indicated their conceptions of academic and social ability as stable to external forces and to internal forces. They also provided information about the importance they place on academic and social competence, their knowledge about academic and social performance, their preference for academic challenge, their perceptions of academic and social competence, and their attributions for academic and social performance. Children's grades in school and their acceptance by peers were obtained as indicators of performance. Over time, conceiving of ability as stable to external forces, particularly in the academic domain, appeared to heighten the importance placed on competence, performance knowledge, preference for challenge, perceptions of competence, and self-enhancing attributions. In contrast, conceptions of ability as stable to internal forces, particularly in the academic domain, appeared to be fostered by placing little importance on competence, a lack of performance knowledge, avoidance of challenge, negative perceptions of competence, self-deprecating attributions, and poor performance.
人们通常认为,将能力视为稳定的会导致消极的自我评估过程,尤其是在面对失败时。然而,对实证研究结果的仔细审视表明,情况可能更为复杂。在这项研究中,采用了一项为期12个月的三波纵向设计。大龄小学生(N = 932)表明了他们对学术和社交能力相对于外部力量和内部力量的稳定性的看法。他们还提供了有关他们对学术和社交能力的重视程度、他们对学术和社交表现的了解、他们对学术挑战的偏好、他们对学术和社交能力的认知以及他们对学术和社交表现的归因等信息。获取了孩子们的在校成绩以及他们被同伴接受的程度作为表现指标。随着时间的推移,将能力视为相对于外部力量稳定,尤其是在学术领域,似乎会提高对能力、表现知识、挑战偏好、能力认知以及自我提升归因的重视程度。相比之下,将能力视为相对于内部力量稳定,尤其是在学术领域,似乎是由于对能力重视不足、缺乏表现知识、回避挑战、对能力的负面认知、自我贬低的归因以及表现不佳所促成的。