Mentzelopoulos S D, Tzoufi M J, Papageorgiou E P
Department of Anesthesiology, Egion General Hospital, Egion, Greece.
Anesth Analg. 2001 May;92(5):1331-6. doi: 10.1097/00000539-200105000-00048.
Orotracheal intubation causes cervical spine (C-spine) extension and potential (hypothetical) space available for the cord (SAC)-deformation. In the present study, we determined and compared the changes induced by conventional- and balloon laryngoscopy-guided orolaryngeal intubation in the upper C-spine's osseous unit-orientation, segmental angulation, segmental SAC-sagittal surface areas (SSAs), segmental/total posterior SAC-aspect, and segmental SAC-width. Eight healthy volunteers were enrolled. A set of neutral head position (baseline)- and two sets of intubation-lateral C-spine radiographs were obtained. Relative to baseline, both intubation techniques induced significant changes in the occiput (OCC)-, third cervical vertebra (C3)-, C4-, and C5-orientation, the OCC-C1-segmental angulation, all the segmental SAC-SSAs, and the OCC-C1-, and C1-2-posterior SAC-aspect (P < 0.05 to < 0.001); conventional intubation caused additional significant changes in C2-orientation, total (OCC through C5)-posterior SAC-aspect, and OCC-C1-SAC-width (P < 0.05 to < 0.001). Relative to conventional intubation, balloon-assisted intubation caused less change in C3-orientation and C2-3-SAC-width (P < 0.05), and less reduction in OCC-C1-, C1-2-, and C4-5-SAC-SSAs (P < 0.05 to < 0.01). Orotracheal intubation should be cautiously performed in patients with space-occupying upper-C-spine-SAC lesions, even if there is no concomitant osseous/ligamentous pathology. In such cases, balloon laryngoscopy may be chosen over the conventional technique, because it causes less SAC deformation.
This study shows that direct laryngoscopy-guided orotracheal intubation causes deformation of the upper cervical space available for the cord, even in the absence of cervical spine instability. These effects are attenuated with balloon laryngoscopy, and thus, its use is recommended in patients with space-occupying lesions within the spinal canal.
经口气管插管会导致颈椎(C 型脊柱)伸展以及脊髓潜在(假设)可用空间(SAC)变形。在本研究中,我们测定并比较了传统喉镜和球囊喉镜引导下经口喉插管对上段 C 型脊柱骨单元方向、节段角度、节段 SAC 矢状表面积(SSA)、节段/总后 SAC 面以及节段 SAC 宽度的影响。招募了 8 名健康志愿者。获取了一组中立头位(基线)和两组插管时的颈椎侧位 X 光片。相对于基线,两种插管技术均导致枕骨(OCC)、第三颈椎(C3)、C4 和 C5 方向、OCC - C1 节段角度、所有节段 SAC - SSA 以及 OCC - C1 和 C1 - 2 后 SAC 面发生显著变化(P < 0.05 至 < 0.001);传统插管还导致 C2 方向、总(OCC 至 C5)后 SAC 面以及 OCC - C1 - SAC 宽度发生额外显著变化(P < 0.05 至 < 0.001)。相对于传统插管,球囊辅助插管导致 C3 方向和 C2 - 3 - SAC 宽度变化较小(P < 0.05),并且 OCC - C1、C1 - 2 和 C4 - 5 - SAC - SSA 减少较少(P < 0.05 至 < 0.01)。对于上段 C 型脊柱 - SAC 有占位性病变的患者,即使没有伴随的骨/韧带病变,经口气管插管也应谨慎进行。在这种情况下,可选择球囊喉镜而非传统技术,因为它引起的 SAC 变形较小。
本研究表明,即使在无颈椎不稳定的情况下,直接喉镜引导下的经口气管插管也会导致脊髓上段可用空间变形。球囊喉镜可减轻这些影响,因此,对于椎管内有占位性病变的患者,建议使用球囊喉镜。