Schneider P A, Caps M T, Ogawa D Y, Hayman E S
Division of Vascular Therapy, Hawaii Permanente Medical Group, Honolulu, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 2001 May;33(5):955-62. doi: 10.1067/mva.2001.114210.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of combining intraoperative balloon angioplasty (IBA) of the superficial femoral artery (SFA) with distal bypass graft originating from the popliteal artery as a method of lower extremity revascularization in diabetic patients with gangrene.
Among 380 infrainguinal bypass grafts performed over a 6-year period, there were 110 reversed saphenous vein bypass grafts to the tibial or pedal arteries to treat diabetic patients with gangrene. Diffuse infrainguinal disease was treated with femoral-distal bypass graft (long; n = 46). Popliteal-distal bypass graft was performed when the inflow femoral artery was not significantly diseased (short; n = 52). Focal SFA stenosis and severe infrageniculate disease were treated with combined IBA of the SFA and distal bypass graft originating from the popliteal artery (combined; n = 12). Follow-up was performed with duplex scan surveillance of both the bypass graft and IBA sites. Treatment groups were compared with life-table analysis.
There were no perioperative graft failures or amputations. The perioperative mortality rate was 1% (1 of 110). The 2-year primary patency rates were similar in the three groups: 72% in the long bypass graft group, 82% in the short bypass graft group, and 76% in the combined group (P =.8, log-rank test). SFA IBA sites developed recurrent stenosis in two patients, at 7 and 48 months; both were detected with surveillance and treated with percutaneous transluminal balloon angioplasty. The overall 5-year rate of primary patency was 63%, secondary patency was 78%, limb salvage was 81%, and survival was 35%. There were no significant differences among the three treatment groups with respect to these outcomes.
Results with the combined procedure were similar to those achieved with either femoral-distal bypass graft or popliteal-distal bypass graft without SFA IBA. These data suggest that IBA of the inflow SFA may be combined with popliteal to distal bypass graft and that this technique is a reasonable alternative to longer, femoral-origin bypass graft in selected diabetic patients with gangrene.
本研究旨在评估将股浅动脉(SFA)术中球囊血管成形术(IBA)与源自腘动脉的远端旁路移植术相结合,作为糖尿病坏疽患者下肢血运重建方法的效果。
在6年期间进行的380例腹股沟下旁路移植术中,有110例为大隐静脉逆向旁路移植至胫动脉或足背动脉,用于治疗糖尿病坏疽患者。弥漫性腹股沟下病变采用股-远端旁路移植术(长段;n = 46)治疗。当流入道股动脉病变不严重时,采用腘-远端旁路移植术(短段;n = 52)。局灶性SFA狭窄和严重的膝下病变采用SFA IBA与源自腘动脉的远端旁路移植术相结合的方法治疗(联合组;n = 12)。通过对旁路移植部位和IBA部位进行双功扫描监测来进行随访。采用寿命表分析法对治疗组进行比较。
围手术期无移植失败或截肢情况。围手术期死亡率为1%(110例中的1例)。三组的2年原发性通畅率相似:长段旁路移植组为72%,短段旁路移植组为82%,联合组为76%(P = 0.8,对数秩检验)。SFA IBA部位有2例患者分别在7个月和48个月时出现再狭窄;均通过监测发现并采用经皮腔内球囊血管成形术治疗。总体5年原发性通畅率为63%,继发性通畅率为78%,肢体挽救率为81%,生存率为35%。在这些结果方面,三个治疗组之间无显著差异。
联合手术的效果与未进行SFA IBA的股-远端旁路移植术或腘-远端旁路移植术的效果相似。这些数据表明,流入道SFA的IBA可与腘动脉至远端旁路移植术相结合,并且该技术对于选定的糖尿病坏疽患者而言,是较长的源自股动脉的旁路移植术的合理替代方法。