Richardson M, Elliman D, Maguire H, Simpson J, Nicoll A
Paediatric Infectious Diseases Unit, St George's Hospital, St George's Hospital Medical School, London, UK.
Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2001 Apr;20(4):380-91. doi: 10.1097/00006454-200104000-00004.
The optimal control of communicable diseases requires accurate information on incubation periods, periods of infectiousness and the effectiveness of exclusion. We collected the available evidence for a wide range of infections and infestations and produced evidence-based guidelines for their control in schools and preschools.
A thorough MEDLINE literature search was conducted on the incubation period, period of infectiousness and effectiveness of exclusion for 41 infections. The quality of the information obtained was indicated by levels of evidence. The information was used to produce guidelines on exclusion, and the recommendations were graded according to the levels of evidence available. Grades A, B and C represented strongly, reasonably and poorly evidence-based recommendations, respectively.
The quality of data obtained was highly variable. Information on incubation periods was obtained for all 41 infections and was generally of good quality. Information on periods of infectiousness and effectiveness of exclusion was of a lesser quality and was found for only 11 and 4 conditions, respectively. There were 3 Grade A, 17 Grade B and 21 Grade C recommendations on exclusion. Examples of exclusion periods include: 5 days for chickenpox, measles, mumps, rubella, pertussis and scarlet fever; and 24 h from the cessation of diarrhea for most gastrointestinal diseases In contrast to existing guidelines exclusion was not recommended for school age children with hepatitis A.
We have been able to present the best available data on the incubation periods and periods of infectiousness of 41 childhood infections. It was possible to produce strongly or reasonably evidence-based guidelines on exclusion periods for approximately one-half of the infections.
传染病的最佳控制需要有关潜伏期、传染期和隔离效果的准确信息。我们收集了一系列感染和寄生虫病的现有证据,并制定了基于证据的学校和幼儿园传染病控制指南。
对41种感染的潜伏期、传染期和隔离效果进行了全面的MEDLINE文献检索。所获信息的质量以证据水平表示。这些信息用于制定隔离指南,并根据现有证据水平对建议进行分级。A级、B级和C级分别代表基于有力、合理和薄弱证据的建议。
所获数据质量差异很大。41种感染均获得了潜伏期信息,且质量普遍良好。传染期和隔离效果的信息质量较低,分别仅在11种和4种疾病中找到。关于隔离有3条A级建议、17条B级建议和21条C级建议。隔离期示例包括:水痘、麻疹、腮腺炎、风疹、百日咳和猩红热为5天;大多数胃肠道疾病在腹泻停止后24小时。与现有指南不同,不建议对甲型肝炎学龄儿童进行隔离。
我们能够提供41种儿童期感染的潜伏期和传染期的最佳现有数据。对于大约一半的感染,有可能制定基于有力或合理证据的隔离期指南。