Doody R S, Stevens J C, Beck C, Dubinsky R M, Kaye J A, Gwyther L, Mohs R C, Thal L J, Whitehouse P J, DeKosky S T, Cummings J L
Department of Neurology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA.
Neurology. 2001 May 8;56(9):1154-66. doi: 10.1212/wnl.56.9.1154.
To define and investigate key issues in the management of dementia and to make literature-based treatment recommendations.
The authors searched the literature for four clinical questions: 1) Does pharmacotherapy for cognitive symptoms improve outcomes in patients with dementia? 2) Does pharmacotherapy for noncognitive symptoms improve outcomes in patients with dementia? 3) Do educational interventions improve outcomes in patients and/or caregivers? 4) Do other nonpharmacologic interventions improve outcomes in patients and/or caregivers?
Cholinesterase inhibitors benefit patients with AD (Standard), although the average benefit appears small; vitamin E likely delays the time to clinical worsening (Guideline); selegiline, other antioxidants, anti-inflammatories, and estrogen require further study. Antipsychotics are effective for agitation or psychosis in patients with dementia where environmental manipulation fails (Standard), and antidepressants are effective in depressed patients with dementia (Guideline). Educational programs should be offered to family caregivers to improve caregiver satisfaction and to delay the time to nursing home placement (Guideline). Staff of long-term care facilities should also be educated about AD to minimize the unnecessary use of antipsychotic medications (Guideline). Behavior modification, scheduled toileting, and prompted voiding reduce urinary incontinence (Standard). Functional independence can be increased by graded assistance, skills practice, and positive reinforcement (Guideline).
明确并研究痴呆管理中的关键问题,并基于文献给出治疗建议。
作者检索文献以回答四个临床问题:1)针对认知症状的药物治疗能否改善痴呆患者的预后?2)针对非认知症状的药物治疗能否改善痴呆患者的预后?3)教育干预能否改善患者和/或照料者的预后?4)其他非药物干预能否改善患者和/或照料者的预后?
胆碱酯酶抑制剂对阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者有益(标准推荐),尽管平均获益似乎较小;维生素E可能会延迟临床恶化时间(指南推荐);司来吉兰、其他抗氧化剂、抗炎药和雌激素需要进一步研究。抗精神病药物对痴呆患者中环境干预无效的激越或精神病有效(标准推荐),抗抑郁药对痴呆伴抑郁患者有效(指南推荐)。应向家庭照料者提供教育项目,以提高照料者满意度并延迟送入养老院的时间(指南推荐)。长期护理机构的工作人员也应接受有关AD的教育,以尽量减少抗精神病药物的不必要使用(指南推荐)。行为矫正、定时如厕和诱导排尿可减少尿失禁(标准推荐)。通过分级协助、技能练习和积极强化可提高功能独立性(指南推荐)。