Bell G K, Goldhaber S Z
Charles River Associates, Inc., Boston, MA, USA.
Vasc Med. 2001;6(1):23-9.
Deep venous thrombosis (DVT) and pulmonary embolism (PE) are serious and costly complications of total hip and knee replacement surgery. The risk of these complications is significantly reduced by prophylaxis. Low molecular weight heparins (LMWH) are being used for this indication with increased frequency. The objective of this study was to assess the cost implications of LMWH for the prevention of symptomatic DVT and PE complications following total hip and knee replacement surgery. The study design was cost analysis based on utilization and the costs of medical resources for prophylaxis and treatment of DVT/PE. A retrospective hospital data set was used to assess symptomatic DVT/PE complication rates and medical resource utilization in patients receiving warfarin, other, and no prophylaxis. The results of a clinical trial were used to estimate relative reductions in risk of symptomatic DVT/PE due to prophylaxis with LMWH. The 7721 total hip and knee replacement patients analyzed were admitted in 1992 in 57 acute-care non-federal hospitals. The measurements were of incremental costs or charges expected to be saved as a result of using LMWH prophylaxis instead of warfarin prophylaxis. Prophylaxis using LMWH rather than warfarin reduces the expected total costs (charges) of treatment by $50 ($193), not including the pharmaceutical costs associated with prophylaxis. The cost reduction in favor of LMWH was sensitive to several factors, including blood monitoring costs and DVT/PE complication rates. Where a reduction of one day in hospital stay could be realized from LMWH's early onset of action, the cost (charges) reduction increased to $226 ($624). In conclusion, LMWH has the potential to offer several short- and long-term cost advantages compared with warfarin, mostly due to lower test costs associated with prophylaxis and reduced complication rates.
深静脉血栓形成(DVT)和肺栓塞(PE)是全髋关节置换术和全膝关节置换术严重且代价高昂的并发症。预防性治疗可显著降低这些并发症的风险。低分子量肝素(LMWH)用于该适应证的频率正在增加。本研究的目的是评估LMWH预防全髋关节置换术和全膝关节置换术后有症状的DVT和PE并发症的成本影响。研究设计是基于DVT/PE预防和治疗的医疗资源利用及成本的成本分析。使用回顾性医院数据集评估接受华法林、其他预防措施或未进行预防措施的患者中有症状的DVT/PE并发症发生率和医疗资源利用情况。一项临床试验的结果用于估计LMWH预防导致的有症状DVT/PE风险的相对降低。分析的7721例全髋关节和全膝关节置换患者于1992年入住57家非联邦急症医院。测量的是使用LMWH预防而非华法林预防预计节省的增量成本或费用。使用LMWH而非华法林进行预防可使预期的总治疗成本(费用)降低50美元(193美元),不包括与预防相关的药物成本。支持LMWH的成本降低对几个因素敏感,包括血液监测成本和DVT/PE并发症发生率。如果LMWH的早期起效能使住院时间缩短一天,成本(费用)降低将增至226美元(624美元)。总之,与华法林相比,LMWH有潜力在短期和长期提供多项成本优势,主要是由于与预防相关的检测成本较低以及并发症发生率降低。