Russell M L
Department of Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alta.
CMAJ. 2001 May 15;164(10):1423-7.
Canada's National Advisory Committee on Immunization recommends that both staff and residents of long-term care facilities be vaccinated against influenza. This paper describes the influenza vaccination policies and programs, as well as vaccination rates, for staff and residents of long-term care institutions in Alberta. Such data have not previously been reported.
Data were collected by means of an anonymous mail survey (with 2 reminders) sent to Alberta nursing homes and auxiliary hospitals in spring 1999.
Of 160 facilities providing long-term care during the study period, 136 responded to the survey (85%). Of these, only 85 provided data on staff vaccination rates, whereas 118 provided data on resident vaccination rates. For institutions reporting this information, the median proportion of staff vaccinated was 29.9% and the median proportion of residents vaccinated was 91.0%. Only 2 facilities reported that staff vaccination was mandatory; however, only one of these had a written policy consistent with the self-report period. Using a travelling vaccination cart, offering vaccination on night shift, and monitoring and providing feedback about staff vaccination rates were infrequently employed as elements of staff vaccination programs, although all were positively correlated with staff vaccination rates. Standing orders for resident vaccination were reported by only 84 facilities. Fourteen institutions required written consent for vaccination from the resident or a relative. Facility requirements for consent to vaccinate from the resident or a relative were significantly associated with mean vaccine coverage: 90.5% coverage for institutions requiring verbal consent, 86.5% coverage for institutions requiring written consent and 95.0% for institutions not requiring written or verbal consent.
Staff vaccination rates in Alberta long-term care facilities are unacceptably low. Changes in staff vaccination programs may improve the situation even in the absence of mandatory vaccination or work exclusion rules. Requirements for written consent for vaccination of residents of long-term care facilities may be a barrier to immunization.
加拿大国家免疫咨询委员会建议长期护理机构的工作人员和居民都接种流感疫苗。本文描述了艾伯塔省长期护理机构工作人员和居民的流感疫苗接种政策、项目以及接种率。此前尚未报告过此类数据。
1999年春季,通过向艾伯塔省疗养院和附属医院发送匿名邮件调查(并提醒两次)来收集数据。
在研究期间提供长期护理的160家机构中,136家回复了调查(85%)。其中,只有85家提供了工作人员接种率数据,而118家提供了居民接种率数据。对于报告此信息的机构,工作人员接种的中位数比例为29.9%,居民接种的中位数比例为91.0%。只有2家机构报告工作人员接种是强制性的;然而,其中只有一家有与自我报告期一致的书面政策。使用流动接种车、在夜班提供接种以及监测并提供工作人员接种率反馈等方式很少被用作工作人员接种项目的组成部分,尽管所有这些都与工作人员接种率呈正相关。只有84家机构报告了居民接种的长期医嘱。14家机构要求居民或亲属书面同意接种。机构对居民或亲属接种同意的要求与平均疫苗接种覆盖率显著相关:要求口头同意的机构覆盖率为90.5%,要求书面同意的机构覆盖率为86.5%,不要求书面或口头同意的机构覆盖率为95.0%。
艾伯塔省长期护理机构工作人员的接种率低得令人无法接受。即使没有强制接种或工作排除规定,工作人员接种项目的改变也可能改善这种情况。长期护理机构居民接种书面同意要求可能是免疫接种的一个障碍。