Hawkins R J, Plancher K D, Saddemi S R, Brezenoff L S, Moor J T
Steadman Hawkins Clinic and Steadman Hawkins Sports Medicine Foundation, Vail, Colo 81657, USA.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2001 May-Jun;10(3):225-30. doi: 10.1067/mse.2001.114679.
In this study, we analyzed the results of two series of patients treated for impingement syndrome by undergoing arthroscopic subacromial decompression (ASD). Patients had not responded to nonoperative treatment. Group 1 included 112 consecutive patients (average age, 41 years) with 96 (77%) patients available for 2-year follow-up. Group 2 (28 patients, 29 shoulders; average age, 43 years; range, 22 to 72) had ASD and the subacromial space digitally palpated to determine if adequate decompression was performed. Twenty-two (85%) of 26 shoulders were available for follow-up. At follow-up, pain, function, range of motion, strength, impingement signs, and patient satisfaction were assessed. In group 1, according to the Neer criteria, 48% of the patients were graded as satisfactory and 52% unsatisfactory. Workers' Compensation patients had a satisfactory rate of 32%, whereas non-Workers' Compensation patients had a satisfactory rate of 59%. Twenty patients had open acromioplasty after ASD. Inadequate decompression was noted in 14 of 20 failed patients. In group 2, 86% of the patients were graded as satisfactory according to the Neer criteria, with 14% unsatisfactory, which included the 2 failures. The 2 (9%) of 22 shoulders that failed the ASD went on to further surgical treatment. Average follow-up was 56 months (range, 13 to 78 months). The average American Shoulder and Elbow Society score at follow-up was 90.4. No difference between Workers' Compensation cases and the other cases was seen (P <.7). Finger palpation can help to improve outcomes by allowing the surgeon to assess the adequacy of decompression.
在本研究中,我们分析了两组因肩峰下撞击综合征接受关节镜下肩峰下减压术(ASD)治疗患者的结果。这些患者对非手术治疗无反应。第一组包括112例连续患者(平均年龄41岁),其中96例(77%)患者可进行2年随访。第二组(28例患者,29个肩部;平均年龄43岁;范围22至72岁)接受了ASD,并通过数字触诊肩峰下间隙以确定减压是否充分。26个肩部中的22个(85%)可进行随访。在随访时,评估了疼痛、功能、活动范围、力量、撞击征和患者满意度。在第一组中,根据Neer标准,48%的患者评定为满意,52%不满意。工伤赔偿患者的满意率为32%,而非工伤赔偿患者的满意率为59%。20例患者在ASD后接受了开放性肩峰成形术。20例治疗失败的患者中有14例存在减压不充分的情况。在第二组中,根据Neer标准,86%的患者评定为满意,14%不满意,其中包括2例治疗失败的患者。22个接受ASD治疗失败的肩部中有2个(9%)继续接受了进一步手术治疗。平均随访时间为56个月(范围13至78个月)。随访时美国肩肘外科协会的平均评分为90.4分。工伤赔偿病例与其他病例之间未见差异(P<.7)。手指触诊可帮助外科医生评估减压是否充分,从而改善治疗效果。