Jones T F, Schaffner W
Tuberculosis Control Program, Tennessee Department of Health, Nashville, Tennessee 37247, USA.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2001 Jul 1;164(1):77-81. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm.164.1.2010108.
Jails are an important reservoir of tuberculosis infection in the United States. Screening for active disease in these high-risk settings is difficult. We used decision analysis to assess the cost effectiveness of routine miniature chest radiography for screening for tuberculosis on admission to jail. Infection rates, probabilities, and costs associated with detecting and treating tuberculosis were derived from published studies. We calculated an average total cost of $6.60 per inmate for routine radiograph screening on admission to jail. The cost of screening for active tuberculosis with miniature chest radiography was estimated to be $9,600 per case identified, compared with $32,100 per case with tuberculin skin testing and $54,100 per case with symptom screening. Chest radiography would also identify substantially more cases than other methods of screening. Screening for tuberculosis with miniature chest radiography is cost effective even under a wide range of assumptions regarding risk factors and prevalence of disease. Miniature chest radiography should be strongly considered as an important tool in the fight to eliminate tuberculosis from the high-risk populations that may be reached through screening in jails.
在美国,监狱是结核病感染的一个重要源头。在这些高风险环境中筛查活动性疾病颇具难度。我们运用决策分析来评估在入狱时进行常规微型胸部X光检查以筛查结核病的成本效益。感染率、概率以及与检测和治疗结核病相关的成本均源自已发表的研究。我们计算得出,每位囚犯入狱时进行常规X光筛查的平均总成本为6.60美元。通过微型胸部X光检查筛查活动性结核病的成本估计为每确诊一例9600美元,相比之下,结核菌素皮肤试验每确诊一例为32100美元,症状筛查每确诊一例为54100美元。胸部X光检查发现的病例也会比其他筛查方法多得多。即便在关于风险因素和疾病患病率的广泛假设下,通过微型胸部X光检查筛查结核病仍具有成本效益。应大力考虑将微型胸部X光检查作为一种重要工具,用于在可能通过监狱筛查覆盖的高风险人群中消除结核病。