Shorr A F, Torrington K G, Hnatiuk O W
Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Service, Department of Medicine, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, DC 20307, USA.
Chest. 2001 Jul;120(1):109-14. doi: 10.1378/chest.120.1.109.
To determine the yield of endobronchial biopsy (EBB) for suspected sarcoidosis, and to evaluate if EBB increases the diagnostic value of fiberoptic bronchoscopy (FOB) when added to transbronchial biopsy (TBB).
Prospective study of consecutive patients.
Pulmonary clinic of a tertiary-care, academic medical center.
Patients consecutively referred for suspected pulmonary sarcoidosis.
All patients having FOB performed underwent an evaluation that included history, physical examination, a chest radiograph, and spirometry. During FOB, airway appearance was recorded and both TBB and EBB were performed in a standardized fashion. Six TBB specimens were obtained, as were six EBB samples. For patients with abnormal-appearing airways, four specimens were obtained from the abnormal-appearing airways and two specimens were obtained from the main carina. In patients with normal-appearing airways, four specimens were obtained from a secondary carina and two specimens were obtained from the main carina. A biopsy finding was considered positive if it demonstrated nonnecrotizing granulomas with special stains that were negative for fungal and mycobacterial organisms.
The study cohort included 34 subjects (mean +/- SD age, 37.9 +/- 6.8 years; 58.8% were male; 64.7% were African American). EBB findings were positive in 61.8% of patients, while TBB showed nonnecrotizing granulomas in 58.8% of subjects. The addition of EBB increased the yield of FOB by 20.6%. Although EBB findings were more frequently positive in abnormal-appearing airways (p = 0.014), EBB provided diagnostic tissue in 30.0% of patients with normal-appearing endobronchial mucosa. There were no complications resulting from the addition of EBB to TBB.
Endobronchial involvement is common in sarcoidosis. EBB has a yield comparable to TBB and can safely increase the diagnostic value of FOB. Pulmonologists should consider routinely performing EBB in cases of suspected sarcoidosis.
确定支气管内活检(EBB)对疑似结节病的诊断率,并评估将EBB添加到经支气管活检(TBB)中时,其是否能提高纤维支气管镜检查(FOB)的诊断价值。
对连续患者进行的前瞻性研究。
一家三级医疗学术医学中心的肺病诊所。
因疑似肺部结节病而连续转诊的患者。
所有接受FOB检查的患者都接受了包括病史、体格检查、胸部X光片和肺功能测定在内的评估。在FOB检查期间,记录气道外观,并以标准化方式进行TBB和EBB。获取6份TBB标本和6份EBB样本。对于气道外观异常的患者,从外观异常的气道获取4份标本,从主隆突获取2份标本。对于气道外观正常的患者,从二级隆突获取4份标本,从主隆突获取2份标本。如果活检结果显示非坏死性肉芽肿,且特殊染色对真菌和分枝杆菌呈阴性,则认为活检结果为阳性。
研究队列包括34名受试者(平均年龄±标准差为37.9±6.8岁;58.8%为男性;64.7%为非裔美国人)。61.8%的患者EBB结果为阳性,而58.8%的受试者TBB显示有非坏死性肉芽肿。添加EBB使FOB的诊断率提高了20.6%。尽管EBB结果在气道外观异常的患者中更常为阳性(p = 0.014),但EBB在30.0%气道内黏膜外观正常的患者中提供了诊断性组织。将EBB添加到TBB中未引起并发症。
结节病中支气管受累很常见。EBB的诊断率与TBB相当,并且可以安全地提高FOB的诊断价值。肺科医生在疑似结节病的病例中应考虑常规进行EBB。