Azer S A, Simmons D, Elliott S L
Faculty Education Unit, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Aust J Rural Health. 2001 Aug;9(4):178-85. doi: 10.1046/j.1038-5282.2001.00359.x.
The aim of this project is to investigate the relationship between medical students' background and their perception of the state of rural health services; willingness to undertake internship training or work as a doctor in a rural hospital; expected benefits and disadvantages of training or working as a doctor in a rural hospital; and factors interfering with acceptance of a job as a doctor in rural areas. A questionnaire-based survey was distributed to 100 first-year medical students attending the Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health Sciences, The University of Melbourne at the end of semester 1. The response rate was 97%, including 44 males and 53 females. A strong relationship was found between rural background and an intention to undertake internship training in a rural hospital (86% of students from a rural background expressed this desire vs 30% of students from an urban background). Furthermore, all students from a rural background expressed a desire to work as a doctor in a rural hospital after completing postgraduate training. Compared to urban students, students from a rural background showed a more positive attitude towards health services in rural areas including public hospitals ( P = 0.02), private general practice ( P = 0.004), ambulance service ( P = 0.0002) and baby health centres ( P = 0.005). Citizenship or gender was not significantly related to the perception of any of these services. The ranking of factors interfering with acceptance of a job as a doctor in rural areas were different for rural and urban students. Students from rural backgrounds reported spouse/partner needs (76% vs 49%, P = 0.038) and school availability for children (59% vs 30%, P = 0.023) as barriers more frequently than urban students, respectively). On the other hand, urban students rated the following factors higher: personal factors (76% vs 53%, respectively), education opportunities (56% vs 24%), social/cultural facilities (50% vs 41%) and the need for frequent travel (29% vs 12%). None of these interfering factors were significantly different. Urban students were more likely than rural students to report that their views were a result of adverse media reports. In conclusion, students from a rural background were more willing to be trained or to work as doctors in rural areas. This was associated with a greater adverse influence by the media upon students.
本项目旨在调查医学生的背景与其对农村卫生服务状况的认知之间的关系;在农村医院进行实习培训或担任医生的意愿;在农村医院培训或工作的预期利弊;以及影响接受农村地区医生工作的因素。在第一学期末,向墨尔本大学医学、牙医学与健康科学学院的100名一年级医学生发放了一份基于问卷的调查。回复率为97%,其中包括44名男性和53名女性。研究发现农村背景与在农村医院进行实习培训的意愿之间存在密切关系(86%来自农村背景的学生表达了这种愿望,而来自城市背景的学生这一比例为30%)。此外,所有来自农村背景的学生都表示希望在完成研究生培训后在农村医院担任医生。与城市学生相比,来自农村背景的学生对农村地区的卫生服务,包括公立医院(P = 0.02)、私人全科医疗(P = 0.004)、救护车服务(P = 0.0002)和儿童保健中心(P = 0.005)表现出更积极的态度。国籍或性别与对这些服务的任何认知均无显著关联。农村和城市学生在影响接受农村地区医生工作的因素排名上有所不同。来自农村背景的学生比城市学生更频繁地将配偶/伴侣需求(76%对49%,P = 0.038)和子女上学便利程度(59%对30%,P = 0.023)报告为障碍。另一方面,城市学生对以下因素的评分更高:个人因素(分别为76%对53%)、教育机会(56%对24%)、社会/文化设施(50%对41%)以及频繁出行需求(29%对12%)。这些干扰因素均无显著差异。城市学生比农村学生更有可能报告他们的观点是受到负面媒体报道的影响。总之,来自农村背景的学生更愿意在农村地区接受培训或担任医生。这与媒体对学生的更大负面影响有关。