Lonjon M, Von Langsdorf D, Lefloch S, Rahbi M, Rasendrarijao D, Michiels J F, Paquis P, Grellier P
Service de Neurochirurgie, Hôpital Pasteur, CHU de Nice-UNSA, 30, avenue de la Voie-Romaine, BP 69, 06000 Nice.
Neurochirurgie. 2001 Sep;47(4):423-9.
We reviewed a series of 14 cases of filum terminale ependymoma and 264 cases in the literature, to study the characteristics of these tumors and specifically to determine factors influencing recurrence.
This series analyzed data between 1984 and 1998. The mean follow-up period was 5.5 years and the median age 40 years. Pain was the first symptom, except in one case, with progressive sensitive-motor deficit. Four patients had a myelography and a CT scan, and ten a MRI. All patients were operated with a total resection in 12 cases. All tumors, except one, were a myxopapillary ependymoma.
Clinical results were excellent in 2 cases, good in 8, stable in 2 and worse in 2. Two patients had a recurrence after an initial sub-total resection, both were operated on again, followed by post-operative radiotherapy. Among the 278 filum terminale ependymoma, removal was total in 200 (72%). A recurrence occurred in 15% of them after total removal, and in 43% after partial removal (p<0.001). Among patients with partial removal, recurrence was observed in 33% of them if they had post-operative radiotherapy, and in 55% of them if they did not have post-operative radiotherapy (p<0.05).
The extent of tumor removal has a statistically significant effect upon recurrence. This review is in favor of post-operative radiotherapy in case of partial removal, but this systematic attitude can be discussed after a critical analysis of this study. Long term follow-up is mandatory due to the possibility of late recurrence.
我们回顾了14例终丝室管膜瘤病例及文献中的264例病例,以研究这些肿瘤的特征,特别是确定影响复发的因素。
本系列分析了1984年至1998年的数据。平均随访期为5.5年,中位年龄为40岁。除1例患者外,疼痛是首发症状,并伴有进行性感觉运动障碍。4例患者进行了脊髓造影和CT扫描,10例进行了MRI检查。所有患者均接受手术,其中12例实现了全切。除1例肿瘤外,其余均为黏液乳头型室管膜瘤。
2例临床结果优秀,8例良好,2例稳定,2例较差。最初次全切除术后有2例患者复发,均再次接受手术,随后进行术后放疗。在278例终丝室管膜瘤中,200例(72%)实现了全切。全切术后15%的患者复发,部分切除术后43%的患者复发(p<0.001)。在部分切除的患者中,接受术后放疗的患者复发率为33%,未接受术后放疗的患者复发率为55%(p<0.05)。
肿瘤切除范围对复发有统计学显著影响。本综述支持部分切除术后进行术后放疗,但在对本研究进行批判性分析后,这种系统性的做法仍可探讨。由于存在晚期复发的可能性,长期随访是必要的。