Sartorio A, Palmieri E, Vangeli V, Conte G, Narici M, Faglia G
Division of Metabolic Diseases III, Istituto Auxologico Italiano, IRCCS, Piancavallo (VB), Italy.
J Endocrinol Invest. 2001 Jul-Aug;24(7):515-21. doi: 10.1007/BF03343885.
Plasma and urinary GH responses following acute physical exercise were evaluated in 19 short-statured children (12 males, 7 females, median age: 11.4 yr, age range: 6.1-14.5 yr, Tanner stage I-III, height < or = 3rd centile for age; 7 with familial short stature, FSS; 8 with constitutional growth delay, CGD; 4 with GH deficiency, GHD) and 7 normally growing, age- and sex-matched control children (4 males, 3 females, median age 11.0 yr, range: 7.2-13.1 yr, Tanner stage I-III). All patients and controls underwent a standardized exercise protocol (consisting of jogging up and down a corridor for 15 min, strongly encouraged to produce the maximum possible effort, corresponding to 70-80% of the maximal heart rate) after an overnight fasting. Samples for plasma GH determinations were drawn at 0 time (baseline), at 20 min (5 min after the end of exercise) and at 35 min (after 20 min of rest); urine samples were collected before (0 time) and at 40, 80 and 120 min after exercise. The distance covered by children with GHD during the test was significantly lower (p<0.05) than in the other groups of patients and controls. No differences in the pattern of plasma GH responses after physical exercise were found between children with FSS, CGD and healthy controls, the maximum percent increase (vs baseline) being evident at 20 min (median, FSS: +1125%; CGD: +1271%; controls: +571%). Children with GHD showed a smaller percent increase (+94%) of plasma GH, significantly lower (p<0.01) than those recorded in the other groups. A significant percent increase (p<0.01) of baseline urinary GH following exercise was found in children with FSS (median: +34%), CGD (+18%) and controls (+44%). Children with FSS and CGD showed a gradual increase of urinary GH, reaching the maximum at 80 min, while healthy controls had a more evident and precocious increase (maximum at 40 min). Urinary median GH levels did not change following physical exercise in children with GHD (-5%, not significant). A significant correlation was found between the maximal percent increase (vs baseline) of plasma and urinary GH following physical exercise (r=0.7, p<0.001). In conclusion, our results show that: 1) plasma and urinary GH responses (as well as the distance covered and the number of steps, i.e. the physical performance) to a standardized exercise protocol are similar in children with FSS, CGD and in normal-statured controls, being unable to differentiate among the "normal variants" of growth; 2) children with GHD, unable to accomplish the same performance of the other three groups, show significantly reduced plasma and urinary GH responses following physical exercise. Although the determination of GH responses to pharmacological stimuli remains the definitive tool for the diagnosis of GHD, these preliminary results seem to suggest a potential role of urinary (and plasma) GH response to a standardized exercise protocol as a safe, acceptable first screening test for GH sufficiency also in children, as previously reported in adults.
对19名身材矮小儿童(12名男性,7名女性,中位年龄:11.4岁,年龄范围:6.1 - 14.5岁, Tanner分期I - III期,身高≤同年龄第3百分位数;7名家族性矮小症(FSS)患儿,8名体质性生长发育延迟(CGD)患儿,4名生长激素缺乏症(GHD)患儿)以及7名年龄和性别匹配、生长正常的对照儿童(4名男性,3名女性,中位年龄11.0岁,范围:7.2 - 13.1岁,Tanner分期I - III期)进行了急性体育锻炼后血浆和尿生长激素(GH)反应的评估。所有患者和对照儿童在禁食过夜后接受标准化运动方案(包括在走廊上来回慢跑15分钟,强烈鼓励尽最大努力,相当于最大心率的70 - 80%)。在0时(基线)、20分钟(运动结束后5分钟)和35分钟(休息20分钟后)采集血浆GH测定样本;在运动前(0时)以及运动后40、80和120分钟收集尿样。GHD患儿在测试期间所跑的距离显著低于(p<0.05)其他患者组和对照组。FSS、CGD患儿与健康对照儿童在体育锻炼后血浆GH反应模式上无差异,最大百分比增加值(相对于基线)在20分钟时明显(FSS中位值:+1125%;CGD:+1271%;对照组:+571%)。GHD患儿血浆GH的百分比增加值较小(+94%),显著低于(p<0.01)其他组。FSS患儿(中位值:+34%)、CGD患儿(+18%)和对照儿童(+44%)运动后基线尿GH有显著百分比增加值(p<0.01)。FSS和CGD患儿尿GH逐渐升高,在80分钟时达到最大值,而健康对照儿童升高更明显且更早(在40分钟时达到最大值)。GHD患儿体育锻炼后尿GH中位水平未变化(-5%,无显著性)。体育锻炼后血浆和尿GH的最大百分比增加值(相对于基线)之间存在显著相关性(r = 0.7,p<0.001)。总之,我们的结果表明:1)FSS、CGD患儿与身材正常的对照儿童对标准化运动方案的血浆和尿GH反应(以及所跑距离和步数,即身体表现)相似,无法区分生长的“正常变异”;2)GHD患儿无法完成与其他三组相同的表现,体育锻炼后血浆和尿GH反应显著降低。尽管测定GH对药物刺激的反应仍然是诊断GHD的决定性工具,但这些初步结果似乎表明,尿(和血浆)GH对标准化运动方案的反应作为一种安全、可接受的儿童GH充足性初步筛查试验可能具有潜在作用,正如之前在成人中所报道的那样。