Lee Harry, Tom Clarrisa
Asian and Pacific Islander American Health Forum, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Asian Am Pac Isl J Health. 1996 Winter;4(1-3):222.
Minority communities are becoming increasingly concerned that the rapid growth of managed care activities will lead to a deterioration of their limited health care services and of the diminution of the primary health care providers. A generally expressed opinion among Asian and Pacific Islander Americans (APIAs) is that where there are underrepresented physicians groups, especially those who are culturally competent and ethnically sensitive, any health care reform strategy to control cost by cutting program funds is likely to compound the problem of underrepresentation of the provider community, and would result in greater medically underserviced areas and populations. In contrast, where there are culturally competent and ethnically sensitive physicians serving their communities, health care is more accessible and of better quality. Physicians and other health care providers working in underserved APIA areas are concerned with the loss of their patients to newly formed health maintenance organizations, the increased hassle of paperwork, the increased levels of patient care activities, and the disincentives and erosion of their financial base. In California, the number of managed care programs leads the nations. Moreover, in seventeen California counties, the Medicaid program is being streamlined under a managed care delivery system. The concern among API communities is the loss of access, availability and acceptability of care. Research and data collection on these issues need to be conducted to assess and evaluate the impact of managed care delivery on the health of these populations. METHODS: Information from literature reviews, data from community health centers, 1990 Census data compiled and analyzed by the Asian and Pacific Islander Center for Census Information and Services (ACCIS) program at the Asian and Pacific Islander American Health Forum, and personal communications were the sources of information for this presentation. FINDINGS: The provision of health care services will be more difficult as the managed care movement grows. The supply of physicians providing primary care to the APIA communities is expected to become more acute. The number of primary care physicians is not sufficient to meet the needs of the APIA communities. CONCLUSIONS: The delivery of medical services must be culturally competent and ethnically sensitive. Special interventions are suggested to improve access, acceptability, and appropriateness of health services for the APIA populations. A mentorship program, beginning in the states with the largest numbers of APIAs targeting high school, college, and post-graduate students is suggested as a method to heighten students' sense of social responsibility, and to create the desire and incentive to work in underserved APIA communities.
少数族裔社区日益担忧,管理式医疗活动的迅速增长将导致其有限的医疗服务恶化,以及初级医疗服务提供者数量减少。亚太裔美国人(APIAs)普遍表达的一种观点是,在医生群体代表性不足的地方,尤其是那些具备文化能力且对种族敏感的群体,任何通过削减项目资金来控制成本的医疗改革策略,都可能使医疗服务提供者群体代表性不足的问题更加严重,并将导致医疗服务严重不足的地区和人群增多。相反,在有具备文化能力且对种族敏感的医生为其社区服务的地方,医疗服务更容易获得且质量更高。在医疗服务不足的亚太裔地区工作的医生和其他医疗服务提供者担心,他们的患者会流失到新成立的健康维护组织,文书工作的麻烦增加,患者护理活动增多,以及他们的财务基础受到抑制和侵蚀。在加利福尼亚州,管理式医疗项目的数量位居全国之首。此外,在加利福尼亚州的17个县,医疗补助项目正在通过管理式医疗服务体系进行简化。亚太裔社区担心的是医疗服务的可及性、可得性和可接受性丧失。需要就这些问题开展研究和数据收集,以评估和评价管理式医疗服务对这些人群健康的影响。
文献综述信息、社区健康中心数据、由亚太裔美国人健康论坛的亚太裔人口普查信息与服务中心(ACCIS)项目汇编和分析的1990年人口普查数据,以及个人交流,是本报告的信息来源。
随着管理式医疗运动的发展,提供医疗服务将变得更加困难。预计为亚太裔社区提供初级医疗服务的医生供应将更加紧张。初级医疗医生的数量不足以满足亚太裔社区的需求。
医疗服务的提供必须具备文化能力且对种族敏感。建议采取特别干预措施,以改善亚太裔人群获得健康服务的机会、可接受性和适宜性。建议启动一个导师计划,从亚太裔人口最多的州开始,针对高中生、大学生和研究生,以此提高学生的社会责任感,并激发他们在医疗服务不足的亚太裔社区工作的愿望和动力。