Saha S K, Darmstadt G L, Baqui A H, Hanif M, Ruhulamin M, Santosham M, Nagatake T, Black R E
Department of Microbiology, Institute of Child Health, Dhaka Shishu Hospital, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
J Clin Microbiol. 2001 Oct;39(10):3583-5. doi: 10.1128/JCM.39.10.3583-3585.2001.
The turnaround time (TAT) for Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi identification and reporting of the antibiotic susceptibility profile was determined for 391 cases of typhoid fever, using the lysis direct plating or lysis centrifugation method of blood culture along with rapid antimicrobial susceptibility testing. The TAT was more rapid (TAT for 90% of the patients [TAT(90)] = 30 h; TAT(100) </= 67 h) than was possible with conventional methodologies and was equivalent to that reported previously using more advanced, costly technologies that are largely unavailable in developing countries. Antibiotic susceptibility profiles, determined by the rapid antimicrobial susceptibility testing method, of randomly selected 60 S. enterica serovar Typhi isolates were identical to those determined by overnight conventional testing. Preliminary assessment of the impact of the reduced TAT on physician practices revealed that initial empirical therapy was prescribed at the time of presentation in most cases (87 of 108 [81%]) despite awareness that the final report would be available on the following day. Patients treated empirically with first-line antibiotics and shown subsequently to be infected with a multidrug-resistant strain benefited most (8 cases), since therapy was changed appropriately on the following day. In an additional 21 cases, therapy with an appropriate antibiotic was initiated after culture results were available. Thus, in approximately one-fourth (29 of 108 [27%]) of the cases, a change in management to an agent active for treatment of the isolate was made after receipt of the test results. However, in no case was therapy changed from a second-line to a first-line agent, even if the isolate was reported on the day after presentation to be sensitive to first-line therapy (33 cases). Ways in which to utilize rapid-TAT result reporting in order to positively influence physicians' prescribing in Bangladesh are the subject of ongoing research.
采用血培养的裂解直接平板接种法或裂解离心法以及快速药敏试验,对391例伤寒热病例测定了肠炎沙门氏菌伤寒血清型鉴定及药敏谱报告的周转时间(TAT)。与传统方法相比,TAT更快(90%患者的TAT [TAT(90)] = 30小时;TAT(100)≤67小时),且与先前使用的更先进、成本更高的技术所报告的结果相当,而这些技术在发展中国家大多无法获得。通过快速药敏试验方法测定的随机选择的60株肠炎沙门氏菌伤寒血清型菌株的药敏谱,与过夜常规试验测定的结果相同。对缩短TAT对医生诊疗行为影响的初步评估显示,在大多数病例中(108例中的87例 [81%]),尽管知道第二天会有最终报告,但在就诊时仍进行了初始经验性治疗。接受一线抗生素经验性治疗且随后被证明感染多重耐药菌株的患者受益最大(8例),因为第二天治疗方案得到了适当更改。在另外21例病例中,在获得培养结果后开始使用适当的抗生素治疗。因此,在大约四分之一(108例中的29例 [27%])的病例中,在收到检测结果后对治疗方案进行了更改,改为使用对分离株有活性的药物。然而,即使分离株在就诊后第二天报告对一线治疗敏感(33例),也没有一例从二线药物改为一线药物治疗。如何利用快速TAT结果报告来积极影响孟加拉国医生的处方行为是正在进行的研究课题。