Wolfangel U, Kayser F H, Munzinger J
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1975 Aug 16;105(33):1047-51.
This study sets out to describe and evaluate antimicrobial therapy in the departments of surgery, medicine, gynecology and obstetrics of a 500-bed general hospital serving a mainly metropolitan population. About one third (605) of 2002 hospitalized patients received chemotherapy, 97 patients being treated for nosocomial infections. In 44% antimicrobials were given prophylactically, chiefly in the surgical department (in 60% of the drug courses) and the departments of gynecology (in 78%) and obstetrics (in 71%). Combinations (excluding sulphamethoxazole/ trimethoprim) were used on the medical wards in 5% and on the surgical wards in 15% of the drug courses. Gentamycin combined with beta-lactam antibiotics was most often used in medicine, while penicillin/streptomycin and ampicillin/cloxacillin in fixed ratios were the most frequent combinations in surgery. Finally, each therapy was evaluated by two experts as either rational, irrational or questionable. 61% of the 681 drug courses were considered rational, 16% questionable and 23% irrational. In the 155 irrational drug courses, one or more of the following criticisms were made: inappropriate chemoprophylaxis (101), wrong drug in chemoprophylaxis (66), inappropriate combination (30), wrong drug in symptomatic chemotherapy (28), no bacteriological diagnosis (26), sensitivity test not considered (17), use of antagonistic combinations (11) and wrong drug in therapeutic chemotherapy (5).
本研究旨在描述和评估一家拥有500张床位、主要服务于大城市人口的综合医院的外科、内科、妇产科的抗菌治疗情况。2002名住院患者中约三分之一(605人)接受了化疗,其中97人因医院感染接受治疗。44%的患者接受了预防性抗菌治疗,主要是在外科(60%的疗程)、妇科(78%)和产科(71%)。联合用药(不包括磺胺甲恶唑/甲氧苄啶)在内科病房的用药疗程中占5%,在外科病房占15%。庆大霉素联合β-内酰胺类抗生素在内科最常用,而青霉素/链霉素和固定比例的氨苄西林/氯唑西林是外科最常用的联合用药。最后,两位专家对每种治疗方法进行评估,判断其为合理、不合理或存疑。在681个用药疗程中,61%被认为是合理的,16%存疑,23%不合理。在155个不合理的用药疗程中,出现了以下一种或多种批评意见:预防性化疗不当(101例)、预防性用药错误(66例)、联合用药不当(30例)、对症化疗用药错误(28例)、未进行细菌学诊断(26例)、未考虑药敏试验(17例)、使用拮抗联合用药(11例)以及治疗性化疗用药错误(5例)。