Hofstra S
Tijdschr Diergeneeskd. 1975 Jul 1;100(13):697-702.
In an introductory part, a number of aspects in the attitude of man towards animals and nature are distinguished, such as an economic, a knowledge, an emotional, a moral, a religious and an ethical aspect. Shifts in the intensity and priorities of these aspects, in the emphasis put on them during various cultural periods, are plainly perceptible and have been so particularly during the past few years: increasing exploitation of animals and nature on the one hand and an increase in sensitivity on the other. Various protective movements have emerged and become active in this sphere during the past 150 years: first, protection of animals, then conservation of nature and, more recently, environmental protection. A special aspect of the exploitation of animals consists in intensive livestock production which has grown considerably during the last few decades. Strong objections to certain features of this system have not only been raised by national and international societies for the prevention of cruelty to animals but also by ethologists. Admittedly, it is difficult to lay down exact criteria of animal welfare (which, for that matter, also is true of criteria of human welfare) but it is essential to a systeem of values which is becoming increasingly sensitive that efforts should be made to alter the current system of intensive livestock production with the aid of the various sciences closely associated with this system as well as by enlightenment of consumers. The question as to what we are allowed to do with animals and that of where the shifting limits of necessity lie are becoming increasingly relevant from the points of view of ethics and science.
在引言部分,区分了人类对待动物和自然的态度中的若干方面,如经济方面、知识方面、情感方面、道德方面、宗教方面和伦理方面。这些方面的强度和优先级的变化,以及在不同文化时期对它们的重视程度的变化,是显而易见的,尤其是在过去几年中:一方面对动物和自然的利用不断增加,另一方面敏感度也在提高。在过去150年里,各种保护运动在这一领域兴起并活跃起来:首先是动物保护,然后是自然保护,最近是环境保护。动物利用的一个特殊方面在于集约化畜牧生产,在过去几十年里这种生产大幅增长。不仅国家和国际防止虐待动物协会,而且动物行为学家都对这个系统的某些特征提出了强烈反对。诚然,很难制定出确切的动物福利标准(就此而言,人类福利标准也是如此),但对于一个越来越敏感的价值体系来说,至关重要的是,应借助与该系统密切相关的各种科学以及对消费者的宣传,努力改变当前的集约化畜牧生产系统。从伦理和科学的角度来看,我们被允许对动物做什么以及必要性的界限在哪里这些问题变得越来越重要。