Reisine S T, Psoter W
Department of Behavioral Sciences and Community Health, University of Connecticut School of Dental Medicine, Farmington 06030-3910, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2001 Oct;65(10):1009-16.
The purpose of this review is to summarize a systematic review evaluating the evidence regarding the association between the incidence and prevalence of dental caries and: 1) socioeconomic status; 2) tooth-brushing; and 3) the use of the baby bottle. Literature was drawn from two databases, Medline and EmBase. Because of limited resources, we did not conduct hand-searching or search unpublished studies. Three thousand one hundred thirty-eight abstracts were identified, 358 reviewed, and 272 papers included in the systematic review. There is fairly strong evidence for an inverse relationship between SES and the prevalence of caries among children less than twelve years of age. The evidence for this relationship is weaker for older children and for adults because of the relatively small number of studies and methodological limitations. There is weak evidence that tooth-brushing prevents dental caries, but it is uncertain whether the effects of tooth-brushing are due to use of a fluoride dentifrice or from mechanical removal of plaque. Finally, the evidence for the relationship between prolonged use of the baby bottle and dental caries is weak. More studies directly aimed at analyzing the relationship between SES and dental caries are needed to identify factors associated with SES that contribute to dental caries risk. Tooth-brushing should continue to be recommended as a measure to prevent dental caries, particularly using a fluoride dentifrice. Recommendations regarding bottle use should continue until clear evidence about the relationship between prolonged bottle use and dental caries can be obtained.
本综述的目的是总结一项系统评价,该评价评估了有关龋齿发病率和患病率与以下因素之间关联的证据:1)社会经济地位;2)刷牙;3)奶瓶的使用。文献来源于两个数据库,即Medline和EmBase。由于资源有限,我们未进行手工检索或搜索未发表的研究。共识别出3138篇摘要,358篇进行了审阅,272篇论文纳入了该系统评价。有相当有力的证据表明,在12岁以下儿童中,社会经济地位与龋齿患病率呈负相关。由于研究数量相对较少和方法学上的局限性,对于年龄较大的儿童和成年人,这种关系的证据较弱。有微弱的证据表明刷牙可预防龋齿,但尚不确定刷牙的效果是由于使用含氟牙膏还是机械清除牙菌斑。最后,长期使用奶瓶与龋齿之间关系的证据较弱。需要更多直接针对分析社会经济地位与龋齿之间关系的研究,以确定与社会经济地位相关的、导致龋齿风险的因素。应继续推荐刷牙作为预防龋齿的措施,尤其是使用含氟牙膏。在获得关于长期使用奶瓶与龋齿之间关系的确切证据之前,关于奶瓶使用的建议应继续沿用。