Tinuper P, Bisulli F, Cerullo A, Carcangiu R, Marini C, Pierangeli G, Cortelli P
Neurological Institute, University of Bologna, Italy.
Brain. 2001 Dec;124(Pt 12):2361-71. doi: 10.1093/brain/124.12.2361.
Ictal bradycardia is a rare, probably underestimated, manifestation of epileptic seizures whose pathophysiology is still debated. Autonomic modifications may result either from a sympathetic inhibition or from a parasympathetic activation probably due to the ictal discharge arising from or spreading to the structures of the central autonomic network. We review 60 cases of ictal bradycardia from the available literature and present three additional cases associated with left temporal lobe seizures studied by autonomic polygraphic ictal monitoring. Only 47 of the 63 reported cases were documented by simultaneous EEG and ECG recordings during an attack. About 76% of patients in whom well-localized ictal discharges were recorded had temporal or frontotemporal lobe seizures. Forty-five cases included information allowing confident localization of the side of ictal onset, and a 26 : 19 ratio of the left versus right side was evident. Simultaneous monitoring of ECG and other autonomic parameters during EEG recording in partial seizures should be performed to gain more insight into ictal semiology. Correlation of the symptoms referred to by patients with changes in autonomic parameters could avoid erroneous diagnosis of non-epileptic attacks and disclose a potentially lethal condition. Our cases confirm the preferential role of the left hemisphere in the genesis of ictal bradycardia and shed light on the relationship between suprabulbar control of autonomic function and partial epileptic seizures.
发作期心动过缓是癫痫发作的一种罕见且可能被低估的表现形式,其病理生理学仍存在争议。自主神经功能改变可能源于交感神经抑制或副交感神经激活,这可能是由于发作期放电起源于或扩散至中枢自主神经网络结构所致。我们从现有文献中回顾了60例发作期心动过缓病例,并呈现另外3例与左颞叶癫痫发作相关的病例,这些病例通过自主神经多导发作期监测进行研究。在63例报告病例中,只有47例在发作期间通过同步脑电图和心电图记录得到证实。在记录到明确发作期放电的患者中,约76%患有颞叶或额颞叶癫痫发作。45例病例包含了能够确定发作起始侧的信息,左侧与右侧的比例为26∶19,差异明显。在部分癫痫发作的脑电图记录过程中,应同时监测心电图和其他自主神经参数,以更深入了解发作期症状学。将患者所述症状与自主神经参数变化相关联,可避免非癫痫发作的误诊,并揭示潜在的致命状况。我们的病例证实了左半球在发作期心动过缓发生中的优先作用,并阐明了自主神经功能的延髓上控制与部分癫痫发作之间的关系。