Shiffman S, Pillitteri J L, Burton S L, Rohay J M, Gitchell J G
Pinney Associates, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213, USA.
Tob Control. 2001;10 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):i24-32. doi: 10.1136/tc.10.suppl_1.i24.
To test the impact of three health messages focusing on vent holes, sensory effects of Light and Ultra Light cigarettes, or health consequences of smoking, respectively, on beliefs and quitting intentions.
In the course of a random digit dialed telephone survey, subjects were randomised to hear one of three messages. To test the effects of the messages, beliefs and quitting intentions were assessed both pre- and post-message.
Daily smokers (n = 2120) of Regular (46%), Light (39%), and Ultra Light (15%) cigarettes in the USA. The sample was weighted to match the US smoker population on age, sex, and ethnicity.
Beliefs were summarised on three dimensions: Safety (reduced health risk), Delivery (lower tar and nicotine delivery), and Sensation (less harsh). Quitting interest was captured by the "quit index", an aggregate measure of quitting interest and intent.
The message focusing on smokers' sensory perceptions of Light and Ultra Light cigarettes resulted in the most positive change in beliefs about safety, delivery, and intent to quit, and was particularly effective among those who believed that these cigarettes were less harsh. The effect was most pronounced among young adults, and among smokers of Light and Ultra Light brands who most endorsed their sensory benefits.
Addressing smokers' sensory experience that Light and Ultra Light cigarettes feel less harsh may be a promising strategy for changing their misconceptions about these cigarettes and enhancing their interest in quitting. Media counter-advertising on Lights and Ultra Lights, focusing on sensory aspects of these cigarettes, may be an important part of tobacco control efforts.
分别测试三条健康信息对信念和戒烟意愿的影响,这三条信息聚焦于通风孔、淡味和超淡味香烟的感官效果或吸烟对健康的影响。
在随机数字拨号电话调查过程中,受试者被随机分配收听三条信息中的一条。为测试这些信息的效果,在信息播放前后均对信念和戒烟意愿进行评估。
美国每日吸食常规香烟(46%)、淡味香烟(39%)和超淡味香烟(15%)的吸烟者(n = 2120)。该样本经过加权处理,以使其在年龄、性别和种族方面与美国吸烟人群相匹配。
信念在三个维度上进行总结:安全性(降低健康风险)、释放量(降低焦油和尼古丁释放量)和感官感受(刺激性较小)。戒烟意愿通过“戒烟指数”来衡量,该指数是对戒烟兴趣和意愿的综合测量。
聚焦于吸烟者对淡味和超淡味香烟感官认知的信息,在安全性、释放量和戒烟意愿的信念方面带来了最积极的变化,并且在那些认为这些香烟刺激性较小的人群中尤为有效。这种效果在年轻人以及最认可其感官益处的淡味和超淡味品牌吸烟者中最为明显。
针对吸烟者认为淡味和超淡味香烟刺激性较小的感官体验,可能是改变他们对这些香烟的误解并增强其戒烟兴趣的一种有前景的策略。针对淡味和超淡味香烟的媒体反宣传,聚焦于这些香烟的感官方面,可能是烟草控制努力的重要组成部分。