Lobell R B, Omer C A, Abrams M T, Bhimnathwala H G, Brucker M J, Buser C A, Davide J P, deSolms S J, Dinsmore C J, Ellis-Hutchings M S, Kral A M, Liu D, Lumma W C, Machotka S V, Rands E, Williams T M, Graham S L, Hartman G D, Oliff A I, Heimbrook D C, Kohl N E
Department of Cancer Research, Merck Research Laboratories, West Point, Pennsylvania 19486, USA.
Cancer Res. 2001 Dec 15;61(24):8758-68.
Farnesyl:protein transferase (FPTase) inhibitors (FTIs) were originally developed as potential anticancer agents targeting the ras oncogene and are currently in clinical trials. Whereas FTIs inhibit the farnesylation of Ha-Ras, they do not completely inhibit the prenylation of Ki-Ras, the allele most frequently mutated in human cancers. Whereas farnesylation of Ki-Ras is blocked by FTIs, Ki-Ras remains prenylated in FTI-treated cells because of its modification by the related prenyltransferase, geranylgeranyl:protein transferase type I (GGPTase-I). Hence, cells transformed with Ki-ras tend to be more resistant to FTIs than Ha-ras-transformed cells. To determine whether Ki-ras-transformed cells can be targeted by combining an FTI with a GGPTase-I inhibitor (GGTI), we evaluated potent, selective FTIs, GGTIs, and dual prenylation inhibitors (DPIs) that have both FTI and GGTI activity. We find that in human PSN-1 pancreatic tumor cells, which harbor oncogenic Ki-ras, and in other tumor lines having either wild-type or oncogenic Ki-ras, treatment with an FTI/GGTI combination or with a DPI blocks Ki-Ras prenylation and induces markedly higher levels of apoptosis relative to FTI or GGTI alone. We demonstrate that these compounds can inhibit their enzyme targets in mice by monitoring pancreatic and tumor tissues from treated animals for inhibition of prenylation of Ki-Ras, HDJ2, a substrate specific for FPTase, and Rap1A, a substrate specific for GGPTase-I. Continuous infusion (72 h) of varying doses of GGTI in conjunction with a high, fixed dose of FTI causes a dose-dependent inhibition of Ki-Ras prenylation. However, a 72-h infusion of a GGTI, at a dose sufficient to inhibit Ki-Ras prenylation in the presence of an FTI, causes death within 2 weeks of the infusion when administered either as monotherapy or in combination with an FTI. DPIs are also lethal after a 72-h infusion at doses that inhibit Ki-Ras prenylation. Because 24 h infusion of a high dose of DPI is tolerated and inhibits Ki-Ras prenylation, we compared the antitumor efficacy from a 24-h FTI infusion to that of a DPI in a nude mouse/PSN-1 tumor cell xenograft model and in Ki-ras transgenic mice with mammary tumors. The FTI and DPI were dosed at a level that provided comparable inhibition of FPTase. The FTI and the DPI displayed comparable efficacy, causing a decrease in growth rate of the PSN-1 xenograft tumors and tumor regression in the transgenic model, but neither treatment regimen induced a statistically significant increase in tumor cell apoptosis. Although FTI/GGTI combinations elicit a greater apoptotic response than either agent alone in vitro, the toxicity associated with GGTI treatment in vivo limits the duration of treatment and, thus, may limit the therapeutic benefit that might be gained by inhibiting oncogenic Ki-Ras through dual prenyltransferase inhibitor therapy.
法尼基蛋白转移酶(FPTase)抑制剂(FTIs)最初作为靶向Ras癌基因的潜在抗癌药物被研发出来,目前正处于临床试验阶段。FTIs可抑制Ha-Ras的法尼基化,但不能完全抑制Ki-Ras的异戊二烯化,而Ki-Ras是人类癌症中最常发生突变的等位基因。尽管FTIs可阻断Ki-Ras的法尼基化,但由于其可被相关的异戊二烯基转移酶——香叶基香叶基蛋白转移酶I型(GGPTase-I)修饰,所以在经FTIs处理的细胞中,Ki-Ras仍会发生异戊二烯化。因此,与Ha-Ras转化的细胞相比,由Ki-ras转化的细胞往往对FTIs更具抗性。为了确定联合使用FTI和GGPTase-I抑制剂(GGTI)是否能够靶向作用于Ki-ras转化的细胞,我们评估了具有FTI和GGTI活性的强效、选择性FTIs、GGTIs以及双重异戊二烯化抑制剂(DPIs)。我们发现,在携带致癌性Ki-ras的人PSN-1胰腺肿瘤细胞以及其他具有野生型或致癌性Ki-ras的肿瘤细胞系中,与单独使用FTI或GGTI相比,使用FTI/GGTI组合或DPI进行处理可阻断Ki-Ras的异戊二烯化,并诱导更高水平的细胞凋亡。我们通过监测经处理动物的胰腺和肿瘤组织中Ki-Ras、FPTase的特异性底物HDJ2以及GGPTase-I的特异性底物Rap1A的异戊二烯化抑制情况,证明了这些化合物能够在小鼠体内抑制其酶靶点。连续输注(72小时)不同剂量的GGTI并联合高剂量、固定剂量的FTI,可导致Ki-Ras异戊二烯化呈剂量依赖性抑制。然而,当以单一疗法或与FTI联合给药时,输注72小时的GGTI(剂量足以在存在FTI的情况下抑制Ki-Ras异戊二烯化)会在输注后2周内导致死亡。在以抑制Ki-Ras异戊二烯化的剂量输注72小时后,DPI也具有致死性。由于高剂量DPI输注24小时是可耐受的且可抑制Ki-Ras异戊二烯化,因此我们在裸鼠/PSN-1肿瘤细胞异种移植模型以及患有乳腺肿瘤的Ki-ras转基因小鼠中,比较了24小时FTI输注与DPI的抗肿瘤疗效。FTI和DPI的给药剂量能够提供相当的FPTase抑制效果。FTI和DPI显示出相当的疗效,可导致PSN-1异种移植肿瘤的生长速率降低以及转基因模型中的肿瘤消退,但两种治疗方案均未诱导肿瘤细胞凋亡出现统计学上的显著增加。尽管FTI/GGTI组合在体外比单独使用任何一种药物都能引发更大的凋亡反应,但GGTI治疗在体内的毒性限制了治疗持续时间,因此可能会限制通过双重异戊二烯基转移酶抑制剂疗法抑制致癌性Ki-Ras可能获得的治疗益处。