Tirosh E, Cohen A, Berger J, Davidovitch M, Cohen-Ophir M
The Hannah Khoushy Child Development Center, Bnai Zion Medical Center, The Bruce Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Haifa, Israel.
Eur J Paediatr Neurol. 2001;5(6):253-8. doi: 10.1053/ejpn.2001.0525.
Specific learning disability in childhood is frequently associated with attention deficit disorder. The distinction between children with and without such comorbidity is often difficult to make. Our aim was to delineate the neurocognitive and behavioural differences between children with specific learning disabilities, with and without attention deficit. Students diagnosed with learning disability, mean age 8.3, 1.4 SD (N-50), and students with learning disability and attention deficit disorder, mean age 8.7, 1.4 SD (N-50), were assessed. The Paediatric Early Elementary Examination and the Aggregate Neurobehavioural Student Health Education Review were administered and their scores as well as pattern of correlations within and between domains were analysed. Only few differences in neurocognitive functions between these groups were evident. Most neurocognitive domains were similarly intercorrelated in the two groups. However, recall was correlated with other neurocognitive domains only among the children with learning and attention deficits. A proportion of significant correlations between neurocognitive and behavioural domains was found among the children with learning disability and attention deficit disorder, but not among the children with learning disability only. It appears that while neurocognitive profiles are similar in these two groups, their interrelationship with behavioural patterns differ. These findings give support to the neurological origin of attention deficit disorder related behaviours among learning disabled children. Different interventions should therefore be considered for each of these entities.
儿童特定学习障碍常与注意力缺陷障碍相关。区分有无这种共病的儿童往往很困难。我们的目的是描绘有特定学习障碍的儿童在有无注意力缺陷情况下的神经认知和行为差异。对平均年龄8.3岁、标准差1.4(N = 50)的被诊断为学习障碍的学生,以及平均年龄8.7岁、标准差1.4(N = 50)的患有学习障碍和注意力缺陷障碍的学生进行了评估。实施了儿科早期小学考试和综合神经行为学生健康教育评估,并分析了他们的分数以及各领域内和领域间的相关模式。这些组之间在神经认知功能方面只有少数差异明显。两组中大多数神经认知领域的相互关联相似。然而,只有在患有学习和注意力缺陷的儿童中,回忆与其他神经认知领域相关。在患有学习障碍和注意力缺陷障碍的儿童中发现了神经认知与行为领域之间的一定比例的显著相关性,但仅患有学习障碍的儿童中未发现。看来,虽然这两组的神经认知特征相似,但它们与行为模式的相互关系不同。这些发现支持了学习障碍儿童中与注意力缺陷障碍相关行为的神经学起源。因此,对于这些不同情况应考虑不同的干预措施。