Wu X, Qi Y, Tang P
Department of Head and Neck Surgery, Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Peking Union Medical College, Beijing 100021, China.
Chin Med J (Engl). 2000 Jun;113(6):532-5.
To compare the epidemiology, local and regional invasion and prognosis of head and neck, malignant fibrous histiocytoma (MFH) and extremity MFH.
Between January 1, 1972 and December 31, 1993, 173 patients with MFH (71 head and neck, 102 extremities and trunk) were referred to the Cancer Hospital for surgical treatment. They were 101 men and 72 women, with age ranging from 13 to 83 years (median: 45 years). The extent of surgery was classified into radical, wide and local resection.
For head and neck, local recurrence of MFH after wide resection was 80.4% (37/46), compared with 36.4% (8/22) after radical surgery (P = 0.000). The five-year survival was 50.79% in all the head and neck patients (74.75% in patients free of local recurrence, 37.74% in patients with local recurrence; P = 0.0181), compared with 70.71% in extremity patients (P = 0.0005). Repeated surgery after recurrence of MFH could cure 40.9% of the head and neck patients and 80.7% of the extremity patients.
Inadequate resection of head and neck MFH in initial surgery is associated with a high incidence of local recurrence, which is always correlated with worse prognosis. Repeated surgery for recurrent head and neck MFH is not as effective as for recurrent extremity MFH. Therefore, we suggest that the initial surgery for head and neck MFH should be as radical as allowed to avoid a possible local recurrence.
比较头颈部恶性纤维组织细胞瘤(MFH)与肢体MFH的流行病学、局部及区域侵犯情况和预后。
1972年1月1日至1993年12月31日期间,173例MFH患者(71例头颈部、102例肢体及躯干)被转诊至癌症医院接受手术治疗。患者中男性101例,女性72例,年龄13至83岁(中位数:45岁)。手术范围分为根治性、广泛和局部切除。
对于头颈部,广泛切除后MFH的局部复发率为80.4%(37/46),而根治性手术后为36.4%(8/22)(P = 0.000)。所有头颈部患者的五年生存率为50.79%(无局部复发患者为74.75%,有局部复发患者为37.74%;P = 0.0181),而肢体患者为70.71%(P = 0.0005)。MFH复发后再次手术可治愈40.9%的头颈部患者和80.7%的肢体患者。
头颈部MFH初次手术切除不充分与局部复发的高发生率相关,这总是与较差的预后相关。头颈部MFH复发后再次手术的效果不如肢体MFH复发后再次手术。因此,我们建议头颈部MFH的初次手术应尽可能根治性,以避免可能的局部复发。