Little B, Mainie I, Ho K J, Scott L
Craigavon Area Hospital.
Ulster Med J. 2001 Nov;70(2):108-10.
The pre-registration house officers (PRHO) is often called upon to interpret electrocardiograms ECG. We invited final-year medical students who had successfully completed their written final examinations, to interpret three rhythm-strip tracings, and three 12-lead ECG tracings. The rhythm-strips were of ventricular fibrillation (VF), ventricular tachycardia (VT), and complete heart block. Of the three 12-lead ECG tracings, one was an inferior myocardial infarction (MI), one was atrial fibrillation (AF), and one showed no abnormality. Forty-six medical students attended. Of these, 50% had received no formal training in ECG interpretation, although 89% had tried to learn ECG interpretation from books. Only 9% felt confident in their interpretation of ECG tracings. Of the rhythm-strips, 100% correctly identified VF, 96% recognised VT, and 67% identified complete heart block. Of the 12-lead ECG tracings, 61 % recognised the MI, 54% recognised AF, and only 46% successfully identified the normal ECG as such. The group were significantly worse at 12-lead ECG interpretation compared to rhythm-strips (p<0.01). The members of the group who had received formal training in ECG interpretation were significantly better at interpreting both rhythm-strips and 12-lead ECG tracings (p<0.05). It would appear that formal ECG training as an undergraduate improves PRHO interpretation of ECG tracings, and the PRHO should not interpret 12-lead ECG tracings without consulting more senior medical staff.
预注册住院医师(PRHO)经常需要解读心电图(ECG)。我们邀请了成功通过书面期末考试的医学专业最后一年学生,让他们解读三份节律条心电图和三份12导联心电图。节律条心电图分别为心室颤动(VF)、室性心动过速(VT)和完全性心脏传导阻滞。在三份12导联心电图中,一份为下壁心肌梗死(MI),一份为心房颤动(AF),一份无异常。46名医学专业学生参加了测试。其中,50%未接受过心电图解读的正规培训,尽管89%曾尝试通过书籍学习心电图解读。只有9%对自己解读心电图的能力有信心。在节律条心电图方面,100%正确识别出VF,96%识别出VT,67%识别出完全性心脏传导阻滞。在12导联心电图方面,61%识别出MI,54%识别出AF,只有46%成功识别出正常心电图。与节律条心电图解读相比,该组在12导联心电图解读方面明显较差(p<0.01)。接受过心电图解读正规培训的小组成员在解读节律条心电图和12导联心电图方面明显更好(p<0.05)。看来本科阶段的正规心电图培训可提高PRHO对心电图的解读能力,并且PRHO在解读12导联心电图时应咨询更资深的医务人员,不应自行解读。