Ohn May Honey, Souza Urban D', Ohn Khin Maung
Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University Malaysia Sabah, Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia.
Department of Biomedical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University Malaysia Sabah, Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia.
Tzu Chi Med J. 2020 Aug 2;32(4):392-397. doi: 10.4103/tcmj.tcmj_91_19. eCollection 2020 Oct-Dec.
Negative affect state toward learning has a substantial impact on the learning process, academic performance, and practice of a particular subject, but such attitude toward electrocardiogram (ECG) learning has still received relatively little attention in medical education research. In spite of the significant emphasis in investigating ECG teaching method, the educators would not be able to address ECG incompetency without understanding the negative perception and attitude toward ECG learning. The purpose of this study was to assess the undergraduate students' difficulties in ECG learning and hence help educators design appropriate ECG learning curriculum to instill competent skill in ECG interpretation based on this outcome.
A total of 324 undergraduate preclinical (year 2) and clinical (year 3-5) medical students participated in this study. The research design used thematic analysis of an open-ended questionnaire to analyze the qualitative data.
The thematic analysis detected five major emergent themes: lack of remembering (18.2%), lack of understanding (28.4%), difficulty in applying (3.6%), difficulty in analysis (15.1%), and difficulty in interpretation (17.8%), of which addressing these challenges could be taken as a foundation step upon which medical educators put an emphasis on in order to improve ECG teaching and learning.
Negative attitude toward ECG learning poses a serious threat to acquire competency in ECG interpretation skill. The concept of student's memorizing ECG is not a correct approach; instead, understanding the concept and vector analysis is an elementary key for mastering ECG interpretation skill. The finding of this study sheds light into a better understanding of medical students' deficient points of ECG learning in parallel with taxonomy of cognitive domain and enables the medical teachers to come up with effective and innovative strategies for innovative ECG learning in an undergraduate medical curriculum.
对学习的消极情绪状态会对学习过程、学业成绩以及特定学科的实践产生重大影响,但在医学教育研究中,这种对心电图(ECG)学习的态度仍未得到足够关注。尽管在研究心电图教学方法方面给予了高度重视,但如果不了解对心电图学习的负面认知和态度,教育工作者就无法解决心电图能力不足的问题。本研究的目的是评估本科学生在心电图学习中的困难,从而帮助教育工作者根据这一结果设计合适的心电图学习课程,以培养心电图解读的胜任能力。
共有324名本科临床前(二年级)和临床(三至五年级)医学生参与了本研究。研究设计采用开放式问卷的主题分析来分析定性数据。
主题分析发现了五个主要的新出现主题:记忆困难(18.2%)、理解困难(28.4%)、应用困难(3.6%)、分析困难(15.1%)和解读困难(17.8%),解决这些挑战可作为医学教育工作者为改进心电图教学与学习而重点关注的基础步骤。
对心电图学习的消极态度严重威胁到获取心电图解读技能的能力。让学生记忆心电图的概念并非正确方法;相反,理解概念和向量分析是掌握心电图解读技能的基本关键。本研究结果有助于更好地理解医学生在心电图学习中的不足之处,并与认知领域的分类法相结合,使医学教师能够在本科医学课程中提出有效的创新策略,以促进心电图学习。