Storey R F, Rowley J M
King's Mill Hospital, Sutton-in-Ashfield.
J R Coll Physicians Lond. 1997 Sep-Oct;31(5):536-40.
To assess the skills and opinions of different grades of doctors and cardiac-trained nurses in interpreting electrocardiographic changes when deciding upon administration of thrombolysis to patients with chest pain.
A questionnaire was distributed to staff in several local hospitals.
Participants were asked to assess 30 electrocardiograms (ECGs) and determine whether they would prescribe thrombolytic therapy on the basis of each one, assuming an associated typical history of acute myocardial infarction (AMI) and no contra-indications to treatment. They were asked to return the questionnaire anonymously, stating only their position.
Of the 88 questionnaires, 61 were returned by 15 senior nurses, 10 house officers, 12 senior house officers, 10 medical registrars, eight consultant physicians and six consultant cardiologists. When electrocardiograms showed unequivocal evidence of acute myocardial infarction, all consultant cardiologists gave the correct answer, but only 75.5% of house officers diagnosed AMI. Cardiologists were most in favour of thrombolysis when left bundle branch block was present. Cardiac-trained nurses showed good decision-making skills.
Staff involved in assessment of patients with chest pain should have specific training in electrocardiographic diagnosis of myocardial infarction in order to minimise in-hospital delay when thrombolysis is indicated. The management of patients with left bundle branch block remains uncertain; cardiologists are more likely to recommend thrombolytic therapy than any of the other participants in the study.
评估不同级别医生以及经过心脏专业培训的护士在为胸痛患者决定是否进行溶栓治疗时解读心电图变化的技能和观点。
向几家当地医院的工作人员发放问卷。
要求参与者评估30份心电图(ECG),并假设患者伴有典型的急性心肌梗死(AMI)病史且无治疗禁忌证,据此判断是否会针对每份心电图开具溶栓治疗处方。要求他们匿名返回问卷,仅表明自己的职位。
88份问卷中,15名高级护士、10名住院医师、12名高级住院医师、10名内科住院医生、8名顾问医师和6名心脏科顾问医生共返回了61份。当心电图显示明确的急性心肌梗死证据时,所有心脏科顾问医生都给出了正确答案,但只有75.5%的住院医师诊断出AMI。当出现左束支传导阻滞时,心脏科医生最倾向于进行溶栓治疗。经过心脏专业培训的护士表现出良好的决策技能。
参与胸痛患者评估的工作人员应接受心肌梗死心电图诊断的专项培训,以便在需要溶栓时尽量减少院内延误。左束支传导阻滞患者的治疗仍不明确;与研究中的其他参与者相比,心脏科医生更有可能推荐溶栓治疗。