Owens Philip N, Walling Desmond E
Department of Geography, School of Geography & Archaeology, University of Exeter, Devon, UK.
Water Res. 2002 Feb;36(3):685-701. doi: 10.1016/s0043-1354(01)00247-0.
The phosphorus content of fluvial sediment (suspended sediment and the < 63 microm fraction of floodplain and channel bed sediment) has been examined in contrasting rural (moorland and agricultural) and industrialized catchments in Yorkshire, UK. The River Swale drains a rural catchment with no major urban and industrial areas, and the total phosphorus (TP) content of fluvial sediment is generally within the range 500-1,500 microg g(-1). There is little evidence of any major downstream increase in TP content. In contrast, fluvial sediment from the industrialized catchments of the Rivers Aire and Calder exhibits both higher levels of TP content and marked downstream increases, with values of TP content ranging from < 2,000 microg g(-1) in headwater areas upstream of the main urban and industrial areas, to values > 7,000 microg g(-1) at downstream sites. These elevated levels reflect P inputs from point sources, such as sewage treatment works (STWs) and combined sewer overflows. The influence of STWs is further demonstrated by the downstream increase in the inorganic P/organic P ratio from < 2 in the headwaters to > 4 in the lower reaches. Comparison of the P content of suspended sediment with that of the <63 microm fraction of potential source materials suggests that topsoil from upland moorland/pasture and from cultivated areas, and channel bank material are likely to be the main sources of particulate P (PP) in the River Swale and in the headwaters of the Rivers Aire and Calder. In the middle and lower reaches of the Rivers Aire and Calder, inputs associated with urban and industrial land uses, such as STWs, industrial effluents and street dust, are likely to represent the dominant sources of PP. During high flow events, such urban inputs may be diluted by inputs from moorland and agricultural land in the headwaters. Consequently, for all three rivers, there are inverse relationships between the TP content of suspended sediment and both discharge and suspended sediment concentration, reflecting changes in sediment and P sources during high flow events. Spatial variations in the P contents of the < 63 microm fraction of overbank floodplain deposits and channel bed sediment evidence a similar pattern as those for suspended sediment, with relatively low levels of TP in the River Swale and elevated levels in the middle and downstream reaches of the Rivers Aire and Calder. The PP concentrations associated with floodplain and channel bed sediment are, however, lower than equivalent values for suspended sediment, and this primarily reflects the differences in the particle size composition between the three types of sediments. Rates of floodplain deposition and the amounts of fine-grained sediment stored in the river channels are relatively high, and suggest that such environments may represent important sinks for PP. Based on the sediment samples collected from the study basins, a simple four-fold classification which relates the TP content of suspended sediment to upstream land use has been established. Both the range and the absolute values of TP content tend to increase with an increase in the level of urbanization and industrialization.
在英国约克郡,对农村(荒地和农业区)和工业化集水区的河流沉积物(悬浮沉积物以及泛滥平原和河床沉积物中粒径小于63微米的部分)中的磷含量进行了对比研究。斯韦尔河流经一个没有主要城市和工业区的农村集水区,河流沉积物中的总磷(TP)含量一般在500 - 1500微克/克范围内。几乎没有证据表明TP含量在下游有任何显著增加。相比之下,艾尔河和卡尔德河工业化集水区的河流沉积物不仅TP含量更高,而且在下游有明显增加,TP含量值从主要城市和工业区上游源头地区的小于2000微克/克,到下游站点的大于7000微克/克。这些升高的水平反映了来自点源的磷输入,如污水处理厂(STW)和合流污水溢流。污水处理厂的影响还通过无机磷/有机磷比率从源头的小于2增加到下游的大于4进一步体现出来。将悬浮沉积物的磷含量与潜在源物质中粒径小于63微米部分的磷含量进行比较表明,高地荒地/牧场和耕地的表土以及河岸物质可能是斯韦尔河以及艾尔河和卡尔德河源头颗粒态磷(PP)的主要来源。在艾尔河和卡尔德河的中下游,与城市和工业土地利用相关的输入,如污水处理厂、工业废水和街道灰尘,可能是PP的主要来源。在高流量事件期间,这种城市输入可能会被源头荒地和农业用地的输入所稀释。因此,对于所有三条河流,悬浮沉积物中的TP含量与流量和悬浮沉积物浓度之间都存在反比关系,这反映了高流量事件期间沉积物和磷源的变化。泛滥平原沉积物和河床沉积物中粒径小于63微米部分的磷含量的空间变化显示出与悬浮沉积物类似的模式,斯韦尔河的TP水平相对较低,而艾尔河和卡尔德河中下游的TP水平较高。然而,与泛滥平原和河床沉积物相关的PP浓度低于悬浮沉积物的等效值,这主要反映了三种沉积物类型之间粒度组成的差异。泛滥平原沉积速率和河道中储存的细颗粒沉积物数量相对较高,这表明这些环境可能是PP的重要汇。基于从研究流域采集的沉积物样本,建立了一种简单的四级分类方法,该方法将悬浮沉积物的TP含量与上游土地利用联系起来。TP含量的范围和绝对值都倾向于随着城市化和工业化水平的提高而增加。