de Lucia E, Lemma F, Tesfaye F, Demisse T, Ismail S
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Public Health Nutrition Unit, London, UK.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 2002 Feb;56(2):91-5. doi: 10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601289.
To investigate the use of armspan as a proxy for height in the assessment of nutritional status using body mass index (BMI) for four ethnic groups in Ethiopia.
Cross-sectional study.
Four regions in Ethiopia, namely Oromia, Amhara, Tigre and Somali Region.
A total of 1706 (884 males and 822 females) Ethiopians aged 18-50 y from four different ethnic groups.
Anthropometric measurements (weight, height and armspan) were obtained using standard techniques. BMI using height (BMI-ht) and using armspan (BMI-as) were calculated, t-tests were used to compare means, and linear regression to investigate the relationship between BMI-ht and BMI-as.
Ethnic and sex differences in the relationship between height and armspan, and their derived variables (BMI-ht and BMI-as), were found. Armspan and height (r=0.83-0.9), and BMI-ht and BMI-as (r=0.89-0.97), were highly correlated in all ethnic groups. BMI-as cut-offs equivalent to the conventional BMI-ht classification of chronic energy deficiency were similar in the Oromo, Amhara and Tigre, but substantially higher in the Somalis.
Armspan can be used as a proxy for height to estimate BMI, but the relationship between the two measures varies considerably with ethnicity and sex. Unless sex- and ethnicity-specific cut-offs are applied, the use of BMI-as using conventional cut-offs will overestimate the prevalence of underweight in these populations.
HelpAge International.
在埃塞俄比亚四个民族中,研究使用臂展作为身高的替代指标,通过体重指数(BMI)评估营养状况。
横断面研究。
埃塞俄比亚的四个地区,即奥罗米亚、阿姆哈拉、提格雷和索马里地区。
来自四个不同民族的1706名(884名男性和822名女性)18至50岁的埃塞俄比亚人。
采用标准技术进行人体测量(体重、身高和臂展)。计算基于身高的BMI(BMI-ht)和基于臂展的BMI(BMI-as),使用t检验比较均值,并通过线性回归研究BMI-ht与BMI-as之间的关系。
发现身高与臂展及其派生变量(BMI-ht和BMI-as)之间的关系存在民族和性别差异。在所有民族中,臂展与身高(r=0.83-0.9)以及BMI-ht与BMI-as(r=0.89-0.97)高度相关。奥罗莫族、阿姆哈拉族和提格雷族中与传统BMI-ht分类的慢性能量缺乏相当的BMI-as临界值相似,但索马里族的临界值要高得多。
臂展可作为身高的替代指标来估计BMI,但这两种测量方法之间的关系因民族和性别而有很大差异。除非应用特定性别和民族的临界值,否则使用传统临界值的BMI-as会高估这些人群中体重不足的患病率。
国际助老会。