Posey Amy J, Dahl Lisa M
Psychology Department, Benedictine College, Atchison, Kansas 66002, USA.
Law Hum Behav. 2002 Feb;26(1):107-25. doi: 10.1023/a:1013833325829.
To combat the effects of pretrial publicity, a court may consider a change of venue, moving the trial to a jurisdiction that has been exposed to little publicity about the case. Social scientists can be of valuable assistance in measuring community attitudes regarding defendant level of guilt and case familiarity. This paper discusses obstacles faced by the authors when conducting change of venue surveys and presenting their findings to the court, including challenges to their ability to act and be viewed as scientists, and pressures to do that which contradicts empirical research in order to please the court. Future research should examine factors predicting judges' decisions on change of venue motions and issues associated with small venues and civil cases.
为了应对审前宣传的影响,法院可以考虑变更审判地点,将审判移至对该案件几乎没有宣传的司法辖区。社会科学家在衡量社区对被告有罪程度和案件熟悉程度的态度方面可以提供宝贵的帮助。本文讨论了作者在进行变更审判地点调查并向法院陈述调查结果时所面临的障碍,包括对他们作为科学家行事和被视为科学家的能力的挑战,以及为取悦法院而做出与实证研究相悖之事的压力。未来的研究应该考察预测法官对变更审判地点动议的决定的因素,以及与小型审判地点和民事案件相关的问题。