Delaney-Black Virginia, Covington Chandice, Ondersma Steven J, Nordstrom-Klee Beth, Templin Thomas, Ager Joel, Janisse James, Sokol Robert J
Division of Neonatal/Perinatal Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Children's Hospital of Michigan, 3901 Beaubien, Detroit, MI 48201-1498, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2002 Mar;156(3):280-5. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.156.3.280.
Exposure to violence in childhood has been associated with lower school grades. However, the association between violence exposure and performance on standardized tests (such as IQ or academic achievement) in children is unknown. It is also not known whether violence exposure itself or subsequent symptoms of trauma are primarily responsible for negative outcomes.
To examine the relationship between violence exposure and trauma-related distress and standardized test performance among early school-aged urban children, controlling for important potential confounders.
A total of 299 urban first-grade children and their caregivers were evaluated using self-report, interview, and standardized tests.
The child's IQ (Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence--Revised) and reading ability (Test of Early Reading Ability, second edition) were the outcomes of interest.
After controlling for confounders (child's gender, caregiver's IQ, home environment, socioeconomic status, and prenatal exposure to substance abuse) violence exposure was related to the child's IQ (P =.01) and reading ability (P =.045). Trauma-related distress accounted for additional variance in reading ability (P =.01). Using the derived regression equation to estimate effect sizes, a child experiencing both violence exposure and trauma-related distress at or above the 90th percentile would be expected to have a 7.5-point (SD, 0.5) decrement in IQ and a 9.8-point (SD, 0.66) decrement in reading achievement.
In this study, exposure to violence and trauma-related distress in young children were associated with substantial decrements in IQ and reading achievement.
童年时期遭受暴力与学业成绩较低有关。然而,儿童遭受暴力与标准化测试(如智商或学业成就)表现之间的关联尚不清楚。也不清楚是遭受暴力本身还是随后的创伤症状主要导致了负面结果。
在控制重要潜在混杂因素的情况下,研究城市早期学龄儿童遭受暴力与创伤相关困扰及标准化测试表现之间的关系。
使用自我报告、访谈和标准化测试对299名城市一年级儿童及其照顾者进行评估。
儿童的智商(韦氏学前和小学智力量表修订版)和阅读能力(早期阅读能力测试第二版)是感兴趣的结局指标。
在控制混杂因素(儿童性别、照顾者智商、家庭环境、社会经济地位和产前药物滥用暴露)后,遭受暴力与儿童的智商(P = 0.01)和阅读能力(P = 0.045)相关。创伤相关困扰在阅读能力方面解释了额外的变异(P = 0.01)。使用推导的回归方程估计效应大小,遭受暴力且创伤相关困扰处于或高于第90百分位数的儿童,预计智商将下降7.5分(标准差0.5),阅读成绩将下降9.8分(标准差为0.66)。
在本研究中,幼儿遭受暴力和创伤相关困扰与智商和阅读成绩大幅下降有关。